Putterman C, Lossos I S
Department of Internal Medicine A, Hadassah University Hospital, Jerusalem, Israel.
Isr J Med Sci. 1991 Feb;27(2):109-12.
The high rate of citation errors in bibliographies in medical journals has been a source of concern in recent years. We examined the accuracy of references published during 1 year in two Israeli medical journals. Only two-thirds of the randomly selected references examined were error free; 8% had major errors preventing identification of the cited article. Most of the errors found (76%) were in referencing the author(s) or title of the article. We conclude that errors in citation appear also in Israeli medical journals. Editors should emphasize the importance of reference verification; however, primary responsibility for the accuracy of the reference list rests with the author. Authors should exercise more care in preparing bibliographies and should invest more effort in verification of quoted references.
近年来,医学期刊参考文献中的高引用错误率一直令人担忧。我们检查了两份以色列医学期刊在一年中发表的参考文献的准确性。在所检查的随机选择的参考文献中,只有三分之二没有错误;8%有严重错误,无法识别被引用的文章。发现的大多数错误(76%)在于引用文章的作者或标题。我们得出结论,引用错误在以色列医学期刊中也存在。编辑应强调参考文献核实的重要性;然而,参考文献列表准确性的主要责任在于作者。作者在编写参考文献时应更加谨慎,并应投入更多精力核实引用的参考文献。