Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Population Studies, Institute of Public Health, Jagiellonian University Medical College, Krakow, Poland.
Kardiol Pol. 2009 Dec;67(12):1353-9.
Both in the European and Polish guidelines, the highest priority for preventive cardiology was given to patients with established coronary artery disease (CAD). The Cracovian Program for Secondary Prevention of Ischaemic Heart Disease was introduced in 1996 to assess and improve the quality of clinical care in secondary prevention. Departments of cardiology of five participating hospitals serving the area of the city of Kraków and surrounding districts (former Kraków Voivodship) inhabited by a population of 1 200 000 took part in the surveys. In 1999/2000 and 2006/2007 the same hospitals joined the EUROASPIRE (European Action on Secondary Prevention through Intervention to Reduce Events) II and III surveys. The goal of the EUROASPIRE surveys was to assess to what extent the recommendations of the Joint Task Force of International Scientific Societies were implemented into clinical practice.
To compare the quality of secondary prevention in the post-discharge period in Kraków in 1997/1998, 1999/2000 and 2006/2007.
Consecutive patients hospitalised from 1 July 1996 to 31 September 1997 (first survey), from 1 March 1998 to 30 March 1999 (second survey), and from 1 April 2005 to 31 July 2006 (third survey) due to acute myocardial infarction, unstable angina or for myocardial revascularisation procedures, below the age of 71 years were identified and then followed up, interviewed and examined 6-18 months after discharge.
The number of patients who participated in the follow-up examinations was 418 (78.0%) in the first survey, 427 (82.9%) in the second and 427 (79.1%) in the third survey. The use of cardioprotective medication increased significantly: antiplatelets from 76.1% (1997/1998) to 86.9% (1999/2000) and 90.1% (2006/2007), beta-blockers from 59.1% (1997/1998) to 63.9% (1999/2000) and 87.5% (2006/2007), and ACE inhibitors/sartans from 45.9% (1997/1998) to 79.0% (2006/2007). The proportion of patients taking lipid lowering agents increased from 34.0% (1997/1998) to 41.9% (1999/2000) and 86.8% (2006/2007). Simultaneously, a significant improvement in the control of hyperlipidemia could be noted. In 2006/07, over 60% had a serum LDL cholesterol < 2.5 mmol/l. No significant change was found in the proportion of subjects with well-controlled hypertension or diabetes. In 2006/2007, elevated blood pressure was found in 46.6% of participants and glucose > 7 mmol/l in 13.4%. There was no significant change in smoking rates (16.3 vs. 15.9 vs. 19.2%). The proportion of obese patients increased reaching 33.9% in 2006/2007.
The implementation of CAD prevention guidelines into clinical practice over the decade from 1997/1998 to 2006/2007 changed significantly. The use of cardioprotective drugs increased largely but among risk factors a significant improvement could be found only in the case of hypercholesterolemia. No improvement in the control of hypertension and diabetes, no change in smoking rates and increasing prevalence of obesity suggest insufficient lifestyle modifications in CAD patients.
在欧洲和波兰的指南中,预防心脏病学的最高优先级被赋予了已经患有冠状动脉疾病(CAD)的患者。1996 年引入了克拉科夫缺血性心脏病二级预防计划,以评估和改善二级预防中的临床护理质量。来自克拉科夫市和周边地区(前克拉科夫省)的五家参与医院的心脏病科参与了调查。1999/2000 年和 2006/2007 年,同样的医院加入了 EUROASPIRE(通过干预减少事件的二级预防的国际科学学会联合行动)第二和第三项调查。EUROASPIRE 调查的目标是评估国际科学学会联合工作组的建议在临床实践中的实施程度。
比较 1997/1998 年、1999/2000 年和 2006/2007 年克拉科夫出院后期间二级预防的质量。
连续识别因急性心肌梗死、不稳定型心绞痛或进行心肌血运重建而于 1996 年 7 月 1 日至 1997 年 9 月 31 日(第一次调查)、1998 年 3 月 1 日至 1999 年 3 月 30 日(第二次调查)和 2005 年 4 月 1 日至 2006 年 7 月 31 日(第三次调查)住院的患者,并对其进行随访、访谈和检查,随访时间为出院后 6-18 个月。
在第一次调查中,有 418 名(78.0%)患者参加了随访检查,在第二次调查中有 427 名(82.9%)患者参加,在第三次调查中有 427 名(79.1%)患者参加。心脏保护药物的使用显著增加:抗血小板药物从 76.1%(1997/1998 年)增加到 86.9%(1999/2000 年)和 90.1%(2006/2007 年),β受体阻滞剂从 59.1%(1997/1998 年)增加到 63.9%(1999/2000 年)和 87.5%(2006/2007 年),ACE 抑制剂/沙坦类药物从 45.9%(1997/1998 年)增加到 79.0%(2006/2007 年)。服用降脂药物的患者比例从 34.0%(1997/1998 年)增加到 41.9%(1999/2000 年)和 86.8%(2006/2007 年)。同时,血脂异常的控制也得到了显著改善。在 2006/07 年,超过 60%的患者 LDL 胆固醇<2.5mmol/L。高血压或糖尿病患者的控制率没有显著变化。在 2006/2007 年,46.6%的参与者血压升高,13.4%的参与者血糖>7mmol/L。吸烟率(16.3%比 15.9%比 19.2%)没有显著变化。肥胖患者的比例增加,2006/2007 年达到 33.9%。
从 1997/1998 年到 2006/2007 年的十年间,CAD 预防指南在临床实践中的实施发生了显著变化。心脏保护药物的使用大大增加,但在危险因素中,只有高胆固醇血症得到了显著改善。高血压和糖尿病的控制没有改善,吸烟率没有变化,肥胖的流行趋势增加,表明 CAD 患者的生活方式改变不足。