Department of Psychology, National Taiwan University, Taipei, Taiwan.
Neuroimage. 2010 Apr 15;50(3):1280-91. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2009.12.099. Epub 2010 Jan 6.
Japanese and Chinese both share the same ideographic/logographic character system. How these characters are processed, however, is inherently different for each language. We harnessed the unique property of homophone judgment in Japanese kanji to provide an analogous Chinese condition using event-related functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) in 33 native Japanese speakers. We compared two types of kanji: (1) kanji that usually evokes only one pronunciation to Japanese speakers, which is representative of most Chinese characters (monophonic character); (2) kanji that evoked multiple pronunciation candidates, which is typical in Japanese kanji (heterophonic character). Results showed that character pairs with multiple sound possibilities increased activation in posterior regions of the left, middle and inferior frontal gyri (MFG and IFG), the bilateral anterior insulae, and the left anterior cingulate cortex as compared with those of kanji with only one sound. The activity seen in the MFG, dorsal IFG, and ventral IFG in the left posterior lateral prefrontal cortex, which was thought to correspond with language components of orthography, phonology, and semantics, respectively, was discussed in regards to their potentially important roles in information selection among competing sources of the components. A comparison with previous studies suggested that detailed analyses of activation in these language areas could explain differences between Japanese and Chinese, such as a greater involvement of the prefrontal language production regions for Japanese, whereas, for Chinese there is more phonological processing of inputs in the superior temporal gyrus.
日语和汉语都使用表意文字系统。然而,这两种语言对这些字符的处理方式却大不相同。我们利用日语汉字同音判断的独特属性,利用事件相关功能磁共振成像(fMRI)技术,在 33 名母语为日语的日本人中,为汉语提供了类似的条件。我们比较了两种类型的汉字:(1)对日本人来说通常只有一种发音的汉字,这代表了大多数汉字(单音字);(2)有多种发音候选的汉字,这在日语汉字中很常见(多音字)。结果表明,与只有一种发音的汉字相比,具有多种发音可能性的汉字对会增加左、中、下额下回(MFG 和 IFG)、双侧前岛叶和左前扣带回皮质的激活。在左后外侧前额叶的 MFG、背侧 IFG 和腹侧 IFG 中观察到的活动,分别被认为对应于字形、音韵和语义的语言成分,被讨论为它们在语言成分的竞争来源之间进行信息选择的潜在重要作用。与之前的研究进行比较表明,对这些语言区域的激活进行详细分析,可以解释日语和汉语之间的差异,例如日语中涉及更多的前额叶语言产生区域,而对于汉语,在颞上回中对输入进行更多的语音处理。