Antikainen R
Hoitotiede. 1991;3(1):32-9.
The importance of democratizing the therapeutic process in a psychiatric ward has been emphasized by Hägglund and Pylkkänen (1980). In spite of different levels of training extensive participating of the team members in performing individual psychotherapy promotes the unity of the therapeutic views of the staff. It prevents the formation of antitherapeutic staff groups. The subjective outcome of the treatment on a psychiatric open ward was examined using a questionnaire to patients. All those patients (N = 55) were selected who during a two years' research period stayed at least three weeks on the ward. Three subsamples were formed according to the therapist's occupation: a. patients of registered psychiatric nurses, b. patients of assistant psychiatric nurses and c. patients of residents, psychologists and social workers. There were no significant differences in the evaluations of the general treatment outcome between these three groups. Instead, the occupational background correlated with the patient's evaluation of the importance of the personal therapeutic relationship. The therapeutic relationship with a registered psychiatric nurse or with an assistant psychiatric nurse was significantly more often evaluated to be very or rather important at the end of the treatment than a relationship with a member of the group c. It was concluded that the goal to delegate the psychotherapeutic activities to the whole staff had been achieved quite well. The patients did not devaluate therapeutic relationships with staff members from a lower level of occupational training, on the contrary. The "non academic" personnel had established good contact with their patients. These observations support the views proposed by Hägglund and Pylkkänen (1980). Individual therapy should not be separated from the therapeutic community and the staff should not be divided into therapists and non-therapists.
哈格隆德和皮尔卡宁(1980年)强调了在精神科病房实现治疗过程民主化的重要性。尽管团队成员的培训水平不同,但让他们广泛参与个体心理治疗的实施,有助于促进工作人员治疗观点的统一。这可以防止形成反治疗的工作人员群体。通过对患者进行问卷调查,研究了精神科开放式病房治疗的主观效果。所有在两年研究期间在病房至少停留三周的患者(N = 55)都被选中。根据治疗师的职业组成了三个子样本:a. 注册精神科护士的患者;b. 助理精神科护士的患者;c. 住院医生、心理学家和社会工作者的患者。这三组对总体治疗效果的评价没有显著差异。相反,职业背景与患者对个人治疗关系重要性的评价相关。在治疗结束时,与注册精神科护士或助理精神科护士的治疗关系被评价为非常重要或相当重要的频率,显著高于与c组成员的关系。研究得出结论,将心理治疗活动委托给全体工作人员的目标已经很好地实现了。相反,患者并没有贬低与职业培训水平较低的工作人员的治疗关系。“非专业”人员与他们的患者建立了良好的联系。这些观察结果支持了哈格隆德和皮尔卡宁(1980年)提出的观点。个体治疗不应与治疗社区分离,工作人员也不应分为治疗师和非治疗师。