Graduate School of Environmental Studies, Department of Psychology, Nagoya University, Nagoya, Aichi, Japan.
Neuroimage. 2010 May 1;50(4):1666-75. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2010.01.030. Epub 2010 Jan 15.
Cognitive science has regarded an individual's face as a form of representative stimuli to engage self-representation. The domain-generality of self-representation has been assumed in several reports, but was recently refuted in a functional magnetic resonance imaging study (Sugiura et al., 2008). The general validity of this study's criticism should be tested by other measures to compensate for the limitation of the time resolution of the blood-oxygen-level-dependent (BOLD) signal. In this article, we report an EEG study on the domain-generality of visual self-representation. Domain-general self-representation was operationally defined as the self-relevance common to one's own Face and Cup; three levels of familiarity, Self, Familiar, and Unfamiliar, were prepared for each. There was another condition, Visual Field, that manipulated visual hemifield during stimulus presentation, but it was collapsed because it produced no interaction with stimulus familiarity. Our results confirmed comparable phase resetting in both domains in response to familiarity manipulation, which occurred within the medial frontal area during 270-390 ms poststimulus and in the theta band. However, self-specific dissociation was observed only for Face. The results here support the conclusion that visual self-representation is domain-specific and that the oscillatory responses observed suggest evidence of face-specific visual self-representation. Results also revealed an inter-trial phase coherency decrease specifically for Self-Face within the right fusiform area during 170-290 ms poststimulus and in the alpha and theta band, suggesting reduced functional demand for Self-Face represented by sharpened networks.
认知科学将个体的面部视为一种代表性刺激,以参与自我表现。自我表现的领域普遍性在几项报告中被假设,但最近在一项功能磁共振成像研究(Sugiura 等人,2008)中被反驳。该研究批评的普遍有效性应通过其他措施进行测试,以弥补血氧水平依赖(BOLD)信号的时间分辨率的限制。在本文中,我们报告了一项关于视觉自我表现领域普遍性的 EEG 研究。领域普遍性的自我表现被定义为与自己的脸和杯子共有的自我相关性;为每个熟悉度、自我、熟悉和不熟悉的级别准备了三个级别。还有另一个条件,视野,在刺激呈现期间操纵视觉半视野,但由于它与刺激熟悉度没有产生相互作用,因此被合并。我们的结果证实了在响应熟悉度操纵时,两个领域中都存在可比的相位重置,这发生在刺激后 270-390 毫秒期间的中线额区,并在 theta 波段中。然而,只有在面对时才观察到自我特异性分离。结果支持视觉自我表现是特定于领域的结论,观察到的振荡反应表明存在特定于面部的视觉自我表现的证据。结果还显示,在刺激后 170-290 毫秒期间和在 alpha 和 theta 波段中,右梭状回区域内的自我面孔的跨试验相位相干性降低,表明自我面孔的功能需求减少,网络变得更加尖锐。