Rajan Gunesh P, Ambett Ranjeeta, Wun Lisa, Dhepnorrarat Rataphol C, Kuthubutheen Jafri, Chow Zenia, Wood Bradley
Dept. of Otolaryngology, Head & Neck Surgery, School of Surgery, University of Western Australia, Level 6, T-Block, Fremantle Hospital, Fremantle, Australia.
Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol. 2010 Mar;74(3):297-301. doi: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2009.12.011. Epub 2010 Jan 15.
Diffusion-weighted (DW) MRI imaging is evolving into an alternative to second look surgery in detection of cholesteatoma recurrence. Insights into the DW MRI appearances of postoperative or inflammatory mucosal changes have recently described using non-echo-planar, turbo spin-echo (TSE) DW MRI which reliably distinguishes between postoperative changes and cholesteatoma. We investigated the use of TSE DW MRI in our pediatric population in order to validate a rapid and cost-effective MRI sequence that can be used to screen for cholesteatoma.
Prospective comparative study with adult and pediatric patients at a tertiary referral centre. Patients in the study underwent TSE DW MRI prior to second look or revision surgery for cholesteatoma. A Siemens 1.5 T scanner was employed, using the HASTE sequence (EPI DW MRI) as well as standard echo-planar DWI, T1 and T2 sequences. The MRI findings were then correlated with the intraoperative findings at surgery 9-15 months after primary surgery, or of revision surgery in the cases that were referred from other centres. Detection and localisation of cholesteatoma on TSE DW MRI were compared with the findings at second surgery, long considered the gold standard for detection of residual or recurrent disease. Scanning time between the TSE sequence and the standard planar DW MR were also compared.
In a cohort of 92 patients, 21 pediatric patients were identified. 15 patients have had their 15 second look or revision procedures and DW MRI prior to their surgery. TSE DW MRI detected cholesteatoma and reliably identified the location of the cholesteatoma in 2 patients whom all had disease confirmed at surgery. The 13 cases with negative preoperative DW MRI for cholesteatoma were all confirmed to be disease free at surgery. Scanning time of the TSE sequence takes 100 s as opposed to 20 min using standard echo-planar DW MRI techniques without the requirement of a contrast agent and without the need for a general anaesthetic for any of the children.
TSE (HASTE) DW MRI is emerging as a cost effective, noninvasive alternative to second look surgery for detection and screening for cholesteatoma in pediatric patients.
扩散加权磁共振成像(DW MRI)正逐渐成为检测胆脂瘤复发的二次探查手术的替代方法。最近使用非回波平面涡轮自旋回波(TSE)DW MRI对术后或炎性黏膜变化的DW MRI表现进行了深入研究,该方法能可靠地区分术后变化和胆脂瘤。我们在儿科人群中研究了TSE DW MRI的应用,以验证一种可用于筛查胆脂瘤的快速且经济高效的MRI序列。
在一家三级转诊中心对成人和儿科患者进行前瞻性比较研究。研究中的患者在因胆脂瘤进行二次探查或翻修手术前接受了TSE DW MRI检查。使用西门子1.5 T扫描仪,采用快速采集弛豫增强序列(HASTE序列,即EPI DW MRI)以及标准回波平面扩散加权成像(DWI)、T1和T2序列。然后将MRI结果与初次手术后9至15个月手术时的术中结果相关联,对于从其他中心转诊的病例,则与翻修手术的术中结果相关联。将TSE DW MRI上胆脂瘤的检测和定位与二次手术结果进行比较,二次手术长期以来一直被视为检测残留或复发性疾病的金标准。还比较了TSE序列和标准平面DW MR的扫描时间。
在92例患者队列中,确定了21例儿科患者。15例患者在手术前进行了15次二次探查或翻修手术及DW MRI检查。TSE DW MRI在2例患者中检测到胆脂瘤并可靠地确定了胆脂瘤的位置,这2例患者的疾病在手术中均得到证实。术前DW MRI检查胆脂瘤为阴性的13例病例在手术中均被证实无疾病。TSE序列的扫描时间为100秒,而使用标准回波平面DW MRI技术则需要20分钟,且无需使用造影剂,也无需对任何儿童进行全身麻醉。
TSE(HASTE)DW MRI正成为一种经济高效、无创的替代方法,用于儿科患者胆脂瘤的检测和筛查,可替代二次探查手术。