Beals Katherine A
Department of Family and Consumer Sciences, Ball State University, Muncie, IN, 47306, USA.
Phys Sportsmed. 2003 Jul;31(7):33-8. doi: 10.3810/psm.2003.07.434.
To describe the nature, scope, and perceived effectiveness of selected National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Division 1 programs for the screening, education, and treatment of eating disorders (ED) and menstrual dysfunction (MD).
Surveys were mailed to the team physician or the head athletic trainer of all NCAA Division 1 schools currently supporting at least two of the following women's sports: cross-country/track, swimming, and gymnastics. The survey contained closed- and open-ended questions to ascertain the types of ED and MD screening, education, and treatment programs and their perceived effectiveness.
A total of 170 surveys were sent, and 81% were returned. Although 79% of schools reported screening for MD, only 24% used a comprehensive menstrual history questionnaire. An MD treatment protocol was used by 33% of schools, and 7% reported withholding those with MD from athletic participation. Screening for ED was reported by 60% of schools, but less than 6% used a structured interview or a validated ED questionnaire. Athletes with confirmed ED were withheld from athletic participation by 21% of the schools; athletes with suspected ED were withheld by 9%. Education about ED and MD was made available to athletes by 73% of the schools, and 61% of the schools made this education available to coaches. However, less than 41% of schools made such education a requirement. Thirty-five percent of respondents perceived their MD screening programs to be successful or very successful, compared with 26% for ED screening programs.
These results indicate a pressing need for more standardized ED and MD screening, prevention, and treatment programs among NCAA Division 1 schools. At the very least, all NCAA-member institutions should implement mandatory ED and MD education for all athletes and athletic personnel.
描述美国国家大学生体育协会(NCAA)第一分区中选定的针对饮食失调(ED)和月经功能障碍(MD)的筛查、教育及治疗项目的性质、范围和感知到的有效性。
向目前支持以下至少两项女子运动项目的所有NCAA第一分区学校的队医或首席运动训练师邮寄调查问卷:越野/田径、游泳和体操。该调查问卷包含封闭式和开放式问题,以确定ED和MD筛查、教育及治疗项目的类型及其感知到的有效性。
共发放170份调查问卷,81%被返还。虽然79%的学校报告对MD进行了筛查,但只有24%使用了全面的月经史问卷。33%的学校使用了MD治疗方案,7%报告禁止患有MD的学生参加体育活动。60%的学校报告对ED进行了筛查,但不到6%使用结构化访谈或经过验证的ED问卷。21%的学校禁止确诊患有ED的运动员参加体育活动;9%的学校禁止疑似患有ED的运动员参加。73%的学校为运动员提供了关于ED和MD的教育,61%的学校向教练提供了此类教育。然而,不到41%的学校将此类教育作为一项要求。35%的受访者认为他们的MD筛查项目成功或非常成功,而ED筛查项目的这一比例为26%。
这些结果表明,NCAA第一分区学校迫切需要更标准化的ED和MD筛查、预防及治疗项目。至少,所有NCAA成员机构都应为所有运动员和体育工作人员实施强制性的ED和MD教育。