Salmasian Hojjat, Rohanizadegan Mersedeh, Banihosseini Setareh, Rahimi Darabad Raheleh, Rabbani-Anari Mahtab, Shakiba Alia, Ferrara James L M
Students' Scientific Research Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Baradaran Soleimani Ave., Qeytarieh, Tehran, Iran, 1938833911.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2010 Jan 20;2010(1):CD005565. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD005565.pub2.
Corticosteroids are commonly used in treatment of acute and chronic graft-versus-host disease (GvHD). Nevertheless, there has been no systematic analysis of effects of their use on the patients' survival and quality of life.
To compare the effect of corticosteroids in treatment of patients with GvHD and to compare the effect of different regimens of corticosteroids.
We searched MEDLINE (up to July 2008), EMBASE (up to July 2008) and the Cochrane Controlled Trials Register (up to July 2008) to identify relevant studies. All of the references were assessed in order to identify additional trials.
Randomized controlled trials of any language were included in the study as long as they met any of the predefined comparisons of interest. The primary outcome in question was the overall survival of the patients. Due to lack of evidence, inclusion criteria was revised during the process of the review to include studies comparing different dosage of corticosteroids.
All derived citations and abstracts were screened by two independent review authors for relevance. For the potentially relevant trials, the full text was obtained and reviewed by two review authors independently. Two review authors completed data extraction independently. After revising the inclusion criteria, this process was retried to ensure all relevant evidence is included in the review.
No studies met the original inclusion criteria but two studies (four articles) met the revised inclusion criteria. As they addressed different clinical questions, meta-analysis was not performed. The outcomes of one study were in favor of efficacy of corticosteroids in inducing an earlier remission of acute GvHD, while the other study reported that early corticosteroid therapy of acute GvHD could not prevent progression of the disease to higher grades, although it was accompanied by a slightly better prognosis in the patients who responded by the fifth day of treatment.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: There is no certain study regarding appropriate use, dose and length of therapy for acute GvHD. Further studies are needed to define the appropriate use of steroids and whether other agents are appropriate as frontline therapy.
皮质类固醇常用于治疗急慢性移植物抗宿主病(GvHD)。然而,对于其使用对患者生存和生活质量的影响,尚未进行系统分析。
比较皮质类固醇治疗GvHD患者的效果,并比较不同皮质类固醇治疗方案的效果。
我们检索了MEDLINE(截至2008年7月)、EMBASE(截至2008年7月)和Cochrane对照试验注册库(截至2008年7月)以识别相关研究。对所有参考文献进行评估以识别其他试验。
只要符合任何预定义的感兴趣比较,任何语言的随机对照试验均纳入本研究。所关注的主要结局是患者的总生存期。由于缺乏证据,在综述过程中修订了纳入标准,以纳入比较不同剂量皮质类固醇的研究。
所有导出的引文和摘要由两位独立的综述作者筛选相关性。对于潜在相关的试验,获取全文并由两位综述作者独立评审。两位综述作者独立完成数据提取。修订纳入标准后,重新进行此过程以确保综述纳入所有相关证据。
没有研究符合原始纳入标准,但两项研究(四篇文章)符合修订后的纳入标准。由于它们解决的是不同的临床问题,未进行荟萃分析。一项研究的结果支持皮质类固醇在诱导急性GvHD早期缓解方面的疗效,而另一项研究报告称,急性GvHD的早期皮质类固醇治疗不能预防疾病进展至更高等级,尽管在治疗第5天有反应的患者预后略好。
关于急性GvHD的适当使用、剂量和治疗时长,尚无确切研究。需要进一步研究来确定类固醇的适当使用以及其他药物是否适合作为一线治疗。