University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland 21201, USA.
Account Res. 2010 Jan;17(1):8-29. doi: 10.1080/08989620903520271.
In the past three decades, there has been an explosion in research to understand the mechanisms of brain function. Recent advances in psychophysiology and neuroscience, while still limited, have sparked great interest in developing technologies that could peer into the brain and be used to identify or indicate certain behaviors. The polygraph (lie detector) represents an old technology used for discerning clues to the human brain; functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) represents one of the newest efforts. The use of these technologies in intelligence and counterintelligence in the field without validation represents a major concern about its usefulness. Both research on this new technology and subsequent use on public raise ethical challenges. This article will address the overall ethical issues associated with these new technologies. The report identifies the ethical and cultural challenges in conducting research on these new tools, explores the possibility of using current U.S. regulatory requirements regarding drugs and devices as a model for regulating these new technologies, and suggests approaches for the future.
在过去的三十年中,人们对理解大脑功能机制的研究呈爆炸式增长。尽管最近在心理生理学和神经科学方面的进展仍然有限,但人们对开发能够窥视大脑并用于识别或指示某些行为的技术产生了极大的兴趣。测谎仪(lie detector)是一种用于发现人类大脑线索的旧技术;功能磁共振成像(fMRI)则代表了最新的努力之一。在没有验证的情况下,在情报和反情报领域使用这些技术是对其有用性的一个主要关注。对这项新技术的研究以及随后在公众中的使用都带来了伦理挑战。本文将讨论与这些新技术相关的总体伦理问题。该报告确定了在这些新工具的研究中涉及的伦理和文化挑战,探讨了将当前美国关于药物和设备的监管要求用于监管这些新技术的可能性,并为未来提出了方法。