Thomas B J, Cracchiolo A, Lee Y F, Chow G H, Navarro R, Dorey F
Department of Surgery, Center for Health Sciences, Los Angeles, CA 90024.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1991 Apr(265):129-36.
From 1971 to 1985, 393 total knee arthroplasties (TKAs) were performed in patients for rheumatoid arthritis. Of these, 112 used polycentric prostheses and 131 used total condylar prostheses. One hundred seven of the patients with polycentric prostheses and 102 of the patients with total condylar prostheses were followed for a minimum of two years (average, 61 and 55 months, respectively). At the time of the latest examination, nine knees with polycentric prostheses required revision surgery: six for tibial component loosening and instability and three for patellofemoral pain. Five knees with total condylar prostheses required revision: one for chronic instability, one for a late posttraumatic patellar fracture, and three for late hematogenous infections. The total condylar prostheses with patellar resurfacing had better scores for pain (8.5 points) than the polycentric prosthesis without patellofemoral resurfacing (7.0 points). The total condylar prosthesis appeared more durable in terms of fixation, with no evidence of aseptic loosening of femoral or tibial components noted in this series thus far.
1971年至1985年期间,为类风湿性关节炎患者实施了393例全膝关节置换术(TKA)。其中,112例使用多中心假体,131例使用全髁假体。多中心假体组的107例患者和全髁假体组的102例患者接受了至少两年的随访(平均分别为61个月和55个月)。在最近一次检查时,9例使用多中心假体的膝关节需要翻修手术:6例因胫骨部件松动和不稳定,3例因髌股疼痛。5例使用全髁假体的膝关节需要翻修:1例因慢性不稳定,1例因创伤后晚期髌骨骨折,3例因晚期血源性感染。带髌骨表面置换的全髁假体在疼痛评分(8.5分)上优于未进行髌股表面置换的多中心假体(7.0分)。就固定而言,全髁假体似乎更耐用,在本系列研究中,目前尚未发现股骨或胫骨部件无菌性松动的迹象。