Department of Psychology, University of Bern, Switzerland.
Br J Educ Psychol. 2010 Sep;80(Pt 3):325-40. doi: 10.1348/000709910X485719. Epub 2010 Jan 22.
From the perspective of self-regulated learning, the interplay between learners' individual characteristics and the context of testing have been emphasized for assessing learning outcomes.
The present study examined metacognitive processes in children's test-taking behaviour and explored their impacts on performance. Further, it was investigated whether differences in retrieval processes (operationalized through item difficulty) contribute to performance in strategic regulation skills.
A total of 107 participants (8-/9- and 11-/12-year-olds) solved a cloze test including answerable (easy, medium, and difficult questions) and unanswerable questions about an earlier presented educational film, gave confidence judgments to every answer, and were then allowed to withdraw answers if they wished. Two different scoring schemes for test performance were compared to a control group.
Analyses revealed relatively adequate monitoring processes when metacognitively distinguishing easy, difficult, and unanswerable items and correct and incorrect answers. At the same time, there was developmental progression in the ability to accurately monitor uncertainty. As to control processes, all children proved to be able to adjust their test-taking behaviour to the benefit of test accuracy by withdrawing mainly incorrect answers. Controlling was more efficient for easy than for difficult and unanswerable items.
The study offers evidence for the impact of metacognitive skills in children's learning outcomes and documents strategic behaviour during test taking, as well as developmental progression in the involved skills. Further, findings underline the importance of memory retrieval for subsequent metacognitive processes.
从自我调节学习的角度出发,学习者的个体特征与测试情境的相互作用已被强调,用于评估学习成果。
本研究考察了儿童考试行为中的元认知过程,并探讨了它们对表现的影响。此外,还研究了检索过程(通过项目难度来操作)的差异是否对策略调节技能的表现有贡献。
共有 107 名参与者(8/9 岁和 11/12 岁)解决了一个完形测验,该测验包括可回答(简单、中等和困难问题)和不可回答的问题,涉及之前呈现的教育电影,对每个答案进行信心判断,如果愿意,然后允许他们撤回答案。将两种不同的测试表现评分方案与对照组进行了比较。
分析表明,在元认知上区分简单、困难和不可回答的项目以及正确和错误答案时,存在相对适当的监测过程。同时,在准确监测不确定性的能力上也存在发展上的进步。至于控制过程,所有儿童都被证明能够通过主要撤回错误答案来调整他们的考试行为,以提高测试准确性。对于简单的项目,控制比困难和不可回答的项目更有效。
本研究为元认知技能对儿童学习成果的影响提供了证据,并记录了儿童在考试期间的策略行为,以及所涉及技能的发展进步。此外,研究结果强调了记忆检索对后续元认知过程的重要性。