Alcohol Research Group, 6475 Christie Avenue, Suite 400, Emeryville, California 94608-1010, USA.
J Stud Alcohol Drugs. 2010 Jan;71(1):125-35. doi: 10.15288/jsad.2010.71.125.
In the United States, many people turn to Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) and other mutual-help groups as a first source of help for an alcohol or drug problem, whereas others are introduced to AA while in treatment. Because AA and similar groups in the United States add to the treatment system and function without governmental funds, they represent an important element in ongoing care for individuals with substance-use disorders in the health care system. In countries with free (or more affordable) and more comprehensive systems of care, their role is less clearly defined.
In this study, we compared men and women from representative treatment samples from studies with parallel designs, one Swedish (n = 1,525) and the other American (n = 926), to explore whether rates and correlates of attendance at 1-year follow- up (63% and 78% followed) differ by gender. We explore individual characteristics (demographic, severity, motivational) and formal and informal influences (treatment, mutual help, coercive, social) as possible help-seeking correlates of attendance.
In both countries, similar proportions of men and women attended mutual-help groups. However, twice as many U.S. clients reported attendance. Moreover, twice as many U.S. clients set abstinence as a treatment goal. In multivariate models, having an abstinence goal, a perceived need for treatment, suggestions from one's employment environment, and prior mutual-help attendance predicted posttreatment attendance for men and women in both countries. Gender differences were also found.
Given the stages in which individuals seek care and the cyclical nature of relapse and recovery, mutual-help groups are an efficient resource in the continuum of services.
在美国,许多人将匿名戒酒会(AA)和其他互助小组作为解决酗酒或药物问题的首选帮助来源,而其他人则是在接受治疗时被介绍给 AA 的。由于 AA 和美国类似的团体在没有政府资金的情况下增加了治疗系统并发挥作用,因此它们是医疗保健系统中持续治疗药物使用障碍患者的重要组成部分。在那些拥有免费(或更负担得起)和更全面的护理系统的国家,它们的作用就不那么明确了。
在这项研究中,我们比较了来自平行设计研究的代表性治疗样本中的男性和女性,一个来自瑞典(n=1525),另一个来自美国(n=926),以探讨在 1 年随访(63%和 78%随访)时的出勤率是否因性别而异。我们探讨了个人特征(人口统计学、严重程度、动机)以及正式和非正式的影响(治疗、互助、强制、社会),作为可能的寻求帮助的相关因素。
在这两个国家,男性和女性参加互助小组的比例相似。然而,美国有两倍多的客户报告参加了互助小组。此外,美国有两倍多的客户将戒酒作为治疗目标。在多变量模型中,有戒酒目标、对治疗的需求感知、来自工作环境的建议以及之前参加互助小组,都预测了两国男性和女性治疗后的出勤率。也发现了性别差异。
鉴于个体寻求护理的阶段以及复发和康复的周期性,互助小组是服务连续体中的一种高效资源。