Community Medicine, SMS Medical College, Jaipur, Rajasthan.
Indian J Public Health. 2009 Jul-Sep;53(3):177-82.
BACKGROUND & OBJECTIVE: Janani Suraksha Yojana (JSY) has been implemented in the country to enhance institutional deliveries. This study assess the gaps in delivery services and utilization of resources at Basic and Comprehensive Emergency Obstetric Care Centers (BEmOCs, & CEmOCs), accredited sub centers and private hospitals in district Jaipur, Rajasthan.
The study was undertaken during October-December 2008 in 31 selected health facilities (5 CEmOCs, 4 BEmOCs, 14 accredited subcentres and 8 accredited private hospitals) in district Jaipur. Both primary and secondary data was collected using qualitative and quantitative techniques, by facility survey, interview of service providers (specialists, medical officers, and paramedical staff) and beneficiaries.
There is an increase in institutional deliveries following implementation of JSY. Though the normal deliveries were conducted 24 hours by the BEmOCs and CEmOCs however the necessary drugs like parental antibiotics, mesoprostol, magsulf etc were in short supply and use of partograph was absent at the health facilities. The quality of emergency obstetric care services was still poor due to the lack of blood storage units and anesthetists in CEmOCs. Private accredited hospitals fared better as they had the manpower and managed more complicated cases as compared to government facilities, for caesarean sections. The accredited sub centers were nonfunctional negating the very objective of accreditation. Community is still unaware of the 24 hour stay post delivery and provision of grievance redressal system.
The quality aspects of institutional deliveries are far from desired level mostly because of lack of resources, both manpower and materials; non achievement of IPHS standards etc. The service quality related to antenatal, intranatal and postnatal care need to be improved. The JSY is perceived as an effective scheme by the beneficiaries but gaps in resources and lack of quality of services needs to be adequately dealt with.
印度开展了 Janani Suraksha Yojana(简称 JSY)项目,旨在提高医疗机构分娩率。本研究旨在评估斋浦尔地区基本和综合紧急产科护理中心(BEmOC 和 CEmOC)、认证下属中心和私立医院的分娩服务差距和资源利用情况。
本研究于 2008 年 10 月至 12 月在斋浦尔地区的 31 家选定的卫生机构(5 家 CEmOC、4 家 BEmOC、14 家认证下属中心和 8 家认证私立医院)中进行。通过机构调查、服务提供者(专家、医生和辅助医疗人员)和受益人访谈,收集了定性和定量数据。
JSY 实施后,医疗机构分娩率有所增加。虽然 BEmOC 和 CEmOC 24 小时均可进行正常分娩,但必要的药物如父母抗生素、米索前列醇、硫酸镁等供应短缺,且卫生机构未使用产程图。由于 CEmOC 缺乏血库和麻醉师,紧急产科护理服务质量仍然较差。私立认证医院表现较好,因为与政府机构相比,他们拥有人力,并能够处理更复杂的剖宫产病例。认证下属中心无法运作,使认证的目标化为泡影。社区仍然不知道分娩后 24 小时的留院和提供申诉补救系统。
医疗机构分娩的质量方面远未达到理想水平,主要是因为缺乏人力和物资资源;未达到 IPHS 标准等。需要提高与产前、产时和产后护理相关的服务质量。受益方认为 JSY 是一项有效的计划,但需要充分解决资源差距和服务质量问题。