Department of Philosophy, University of Maryland, College Park 20740, USA.
Neuropsychologia. 2010 Apr;48(5):1495-500. doi: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2010.01.020. Epub 2010 Feb 1.
Successful mirror self-recognition has often been considered a correlate of self-awareness in human development and phylogeny (Gallup, 1982). Studies have also shown that vision and touch interact such that objects viewed in a mirror's reflection are recoded as originating from a location within reachable, or peripersonal, space (Maravita et al. 2002). However, the association of mirror self-recognition and self-awareness is controversial, and the mechanism that underlies the recoding of visual information into peripersonal space remains an open question. In the present study, we address these issues through the novel use of an old paradigm: positive afterimages. It has been shown that when a positive afterimage is induced, and a limb is displaced from its apparent location in the afterimage, the afterimage of the limb fades or "crumbles" (Davies, 1973). We reproduced this effect in conditions where subjects viewed the afterimage of their arms' reflection using a frontally placed mirror and mirror box (Ramachandran & Rogers-Ramachandran, 1996). Our results suggest that the explicit knowledge that one is looking at a mirror as well as online visual feedback from bodily movement are unlikely to be responsible for previously observed interactions between vision and touch. Instead, we propose that a sense of ownership, and (bodily) self-awareness, might in part explain these interactions between vision and proprioception, which provides a partial vindication of the inference from successful mirror self-recognition to self-awareness.
成功的镜像自我识别通常被认为是人类发展和进化中自我意识的相关指标(Gallup,1982)。研究还表明,视觉和触觉相互作用,使得在镜子反射中看到的物体被重新编码为来自可触及或近体空间内的位置(Maravita 等人,2002)。然而,镜像自我识别和自我意识之间的关联存在争议,并且将视觉信息重新编码为近体空间的机制仍然是一个悬而未决的问题。在本研究中,我们通过新颖的使用旧范式来解决这些问题:正后像。已经表明,当诱导正后像时,肢体从后像中的明显位置移位,肢体的后像会消失或“崩溃”(Davies,1973)。我们在使用正面放置的镜子和镜子箱观察手臂反射的后像的条件下再现了这种效应(Ramachandran 和 Rogers-Ramachandran,1996)。我们的结果表明,明确知道自己正在看镜子以及身体运动的在线视觉反馈不太可能是导致先前观察到的视觉和触觉之间相互作用的原因。相反,我们提出,一种所有权感和(身体)自我意识可能部分解释了视觉和本体感觉之间的这些相互作用,这为从成功的镜像自我识别推断到自我意识提供了部分证明。