Kalantar Babak S, Hipp John A, Reitman Charles A, Dreiangel Niv, Ben-Galim Peleg
Spine Research Laboratory, Michael E. DeBakey Veterans Administration Medical Center and Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas, USA.
J Trauma. 2010 Oct;69(4):889-95. doi: 10.1097/TA.0b013e3181bbd660.
The ability to detect damage to the intervertebral structures is critical in the management of patients after blunt trauma. A practical and inexpensive method to identify severe structural damage not clearly seen on computed tomography would be of benefit. The objective of this study was to assess whether ligamentous injury in the subaxial cervical spine can be reliably detected by analysis of lateral radiographs taken with and without axial traction.
Twelve fresh, whole, postrigor-mortis cadavers were used for this study. Lateral cervical spine radiographs were obtained during the application of 0 N, 89 N, and 178 N of axial traction applied to the head. Progressive incremental sectioning of posterior structures was then performed at C4-C5 with traction imaging repeated after each intervention. Intervertebral distraction was analyzed using computer-assisted software.
Almost imperceptible intervertebral separation was found when traction was applied to intact spines. In the subaxial cervical spine, the average posterior disc height consistently increased under traction in severely injured spines. The average disc height increase was 14% of the C4 upper endplate width, compared with an average of 2% in the noninjured spines. A change of more than 5% in posterior disc height under traction was above the 95% confidence interval for intact spines, with sensitivity of 83% and specificity of 80%. Applied force of 89 N (20 lb) was sufficient to demonstrate injury. The combination of assessing alignment and distraction under traction increased both the sensitivity and specificity to nearly 100%.
This study supports further clinical investigations to determine whether low-level axial traction may be a useful adjunct for detecting unstable subaxial cervical spine injuries in an acute setting.
在钝性创伤患者的管理中,检测椎间结构损伤的能力至关重要。一种实用且廉价的方法来识别在计算机断层扫描上未清晰显示的严重结构损伤将是有益的。本研究的目的是评估通过分析在有和没有轴向牵引的情况下拍摄的颈椎侧位X线片,是否能够可靠地检测下颈椎的韧带损伤。
本研究使用了12具新鲜、完整、死后僵硬的尸体。在对头部施加0 N、89 N和178 N轴向牵引时获取颈椎侧位X线片。然后在C4-C5水平对后部结构进行逐步递增的切片,并在每次干预后重复牵引成像。使用计算机辅助软件分析椎间分离情况。
对完整脊柱施加牵引时,发现几乎难以察觉的椎间分离。在下颈椎,严重损伤的脊柱在牵引下平均后椎间盘高度持续增加。平均椎间盘高度增加为C4上端板宽度的14%,而未受伤脊柱的平均增加为2%。牵引下后椎间盘高度变化超过5%超出了完整脊柱的95%置信区间,敏感性为83%,特异性为80%。89 N(20磅)的作用力足以显示损伤。评估牵引下的对线和分离相结合可将敏感性和特异性提高到近100%。
本研究支持进一步的临床研究,以确定低水平轴向牵引是否可能是在急性情况下检测下颈椎不稳定损伤的有用辅助手段。