Subramanian Navin, Reitman Charles A, Nguyen Lyndon, Hipp John A
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX 77030, USA.
Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2007 Mar 1;32(5):518-26. doi: 10.1097/01.brs.0000256449.95667.13.
Cadaveric study of a diagnostic test for cervical spine instability.
Determine if flexion-extension (FE) radiographs can be used to detect incremental damage to anterior cervical structures.
Prior studies have shown that damage to cervical structures can alter motion between vertebrae, and FE radiographs are sometimes used to detect this damage. However, no study has determined if FE radiographs are sensitive and specific for acute injury.
FE radiographs were taken of the intact neck and after each incremental increase in damage to the anterior structures. Intervertebral motion was quantified using previously validated methods. The sensitivity and specificity of intervertebral motion measurements were assessed.
Motion within the intact spines was within normal ranges. Although intervertebral rotation changed significantly after certain anterior structures were damaged, rotation frequently remained within normal ranges, even after extensive damage. A center of rotation that was posterior to the 95% confidence interval for normal motion was 100% sensitive and specific for damage to the anterior structures of the spine.
The results suggest that extensive damage to the anterior cervical spine could be missed if instability assessment was based on intervertebral rotation or displacements measured from FE radiographs. In contrast, a center of rotation that was located posterior to normal was both sensitive and specific for damage to anterior structures.
颈椎不稳诊断试验的尸体研究。
确定屈伸(FE)X线片是否可用于检测颈椎前部结构的渐进性损伤。
既往研究表明,颈椎结构损伤可改变椎体间运动,FE X线片有时用于检测此类损伤。然而,尚无研究确定FE X线片对急性损伤是否敏感且特异。
在完整颈部以及对前部结构损伤每次渐进性增加后拍摄FE X线片。使用先前验证的方法对椎间运动进行量化。评估椎间运动测量的敏感性和特异性。
完整脊柱内的运动在正常范围内。尽管在某些前部结构受损后椎间旋转有显著变化,但即使在广泛损伤后,旋转通常仍在正常范围内。位于正常运动95%置信区间后方的旋转中心对脊柱前部结构损伤的敏感性和特异性均为100%。
结果表明,如果基于FE X线片测量的椎间旋转或位移进行不稳评估,可能会遗漏颈椎前部的广泛损伤。相比之下,位于正常后方的旋转中心对前部结构损伤既敏感又特异。