Ptaszyńska-Sarosiek Iwona, Niemcunowicz-Janica Anna, Janica Jerzy, Dopierała Tomasz, Załuski Janusz, Wardaszka Zofia
Zakład Medycyny Sadowej Akademii Medycznej w Białymstoku, ul. Kilińskiego 1, 15-230 Białystok.
Ann Acad Med Stetin. 2007;53 Suppl 2:39-41; discussion 41.
Medical malpractice results from inadequate professional knowledge, incompliance to the present state of medical knowledge or negligence and inattention. The aim of the paper was the analysis of medical malpractice cases based on material in the field of neurology. The cases were assessed according to the number and type in 32 medico-legal opinions issued by specialist teams of forensic medicine and neurology in the Department of Forensic Medicine, Medical University of Białystok in the years 2001-2006. In 11 cases (34%) medical malpractice was concluded with reference to improper treatment after head injury or brain pathology, inadequate care at neurology unit, lacked or delayed diagnostics of head pathology and injury, non-referral to hospital by neurologists. In the material analysed diagnostic errors predominated. Majority of them originated from the open health care system. Incompetence of neurologists with regard to differential diagnostics resulting in misdiagnosis and improper therapy was noted. In one third of the overall cases medical malpractice was concluded. The most common causes included misinterpretation of disease signs and symptoms, misapplication of available diagnostic potential and unjustified delay before commencing diagnostics.
医疗事故源于专业知识不足、不符合当前医学知识水平或疏忽大意。本文旨在基于神经学领域的资料分析医疗事故案例。依据2001年至2006年期间比亚韦斯托克医科大学法医学系法医学和神经学专家团队出具的32份法医学鉴定意见中的案例数量和类型进行评估。11例(34%)医疗事故涉及头部损伤或脑部病变后治疗不当、神经科病房护理不足、头部病变和损伤诊断缺失或延误、神经科医生未转诊至医院等情况。在所分析的资料中,诊断错误占主导。其中大多数源于开放的医疗保健系统。发现神经科医生在鉴别诊断方面能力不足,导致误诊和治疗不当。在所有案例中,三分之一判定为医疗事故。最常见的原因包括对疾病体征和症状的错误解读、现有诊断手段的错误应用以及诊断开始前无正当理由的延误。