Vizioli Luca, Foreman Kay, Rousselet Guillaume A, Caldara Roberto
Department of Psychology and Centre for Cognitive Neuroimaging (CCNi), University of Glasgow, United Kingdom.
J Vis. 2010 Jan 29;10(1):15.1-23. doi: 10.1167/10.1.15.
Human beings are natural experts at processing faces, with some notable exceptions. Same-race faces are better recognized than other-race faces: the so-called other-race effect (ORE). Inverting faces impairs recognition more than for any other inverted visual object: the so-called face inversion effect (FIE). Interestingly, the FIE is stronger for same- compared to other-race faces. At the electrophysiological level, inverted faces elicit consistently delayed and often larger N170 compared to upright faces. However, whether the N170 component is sensitive to race is still a matter of ongoing debate. Here we investigated the N170 sensitivity to race in the framework of the FIE. We recorded EEG from Western Caucasian and East Asian observers while presented with Western Caucasian, East Asian and African American faces in upright and inverted orientations. To control for potential confounds in the EEG signal that might be evoked by the intrinsic and salient differences in the low-level properties of faces from different races, we normalized their amplitude-spectra, luminance and contrast. No differences on the N170 were observed for upright faces. Critically, inverted same-race faces lead to greater recognition impairment and elicited larger N170 amplitudes compared to inverted other-race faces. Our results indicate a finer-grained neural tuning for same-race faces at early stages of processing in both groups of observers.
人类是处理面孔的天生专家,但也有一些明显的例外。同种族面孔比其他种族面孔更容易被识别:即所谓的“异族效应”(ORE)。面孔倒置比其他任何倒置的视觉对象更能损害识别能力:即所谓的“面孔倒置效应”(FIE)。有趣的是,与其他种族面孔相比,FIE在同种族面孔上更强。在电生理水平上,与正立面孔相比,倒置面孔始终会引发延迟且往往更大的N170。然而,N170成分是否对种族敏感仍存在争议。在这里,我们在FIE的框架内研究了N170对种族的敏感性。我们记录了西方白种人和东亚观察者的脑电图,同时向他们展示正立和倒置方向的西方白种人、东亚人和非裔美国人面孔。为了控制脑电图信号中可能由不同种族面孔低水平属性的内在和显著差异引起的潜在混杂因素,我们对它们的振幅谱、亮度和对比度进行了归一化处理。对于正立面孔,未观察到N170有差异。至关重要的是,与倒置的其他种族面孔相比,倒置的同种族面孔导致更大的识别障碍,并引发更大的N170振幅。我们的结果表明,在两组观察者的早期处理阶段,对于同种族面孔存在更精细的神经调节。