Oblikue Consulting, Barcelona, Spain.
Enferm Infecc Microbiol Clin. 2010 Nov;28(9):590-5. doi: 10.1016/j.eimc.2009.09.010. Epub 2010 Feb 9.
Approximately 4% to 8% of patients with HIV-1 treated with abacavir present a hypersensitivity reaction (HSR). Various studies have shown a direct association between human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-B5701 and HSR to abacavir. The objective of this study was to analyze whether systematic HLA-B5701 testing to prevent HSR in patients treated with abacavir is a cost-effective option for the Spanish National Health System.
An analytical decision-making model was constructed as a decision tree model for a simulated cohort of 1000 HIV patients to evaluate whether HLA-B*5701 testing to prevent HSR to abacavir was cost effective compared with not performing the test. The parameters included in the model and the use of healthcare resources should the patient develop HSR were taken from the PREDICT-1 study and the opinion of clinical experts. The principal result obtained was the incremental cost per HSR avoided. The time horizon of the analysis was to 2 months [corrected] . All costs were expressed in 2008 Euros.
The analysis showed that the total direct healthcare costs per patient were €1344 and €1322 with and without HLA-B*5701 testing respectively, and that 36 cases of HSR were prevented per 1000 screened patients. These results yielded a cost per HSR avoided of €630. The sensitivity analysis showed that the results were sensitive to the cost of the test, with an economic saving of €102 or a cost-effectiveness ratio of €4234.
The model predicts that generalized use of the HLA-B*5701 test before prescribing abacavir in HIV+ patients could represent an economic saving or a limited additional cost for the National Health System which may be counterbalanced by the benefits in terms of a lower incidence of HSR.
约有 4%至 8%接受阿巴卡韦治疗的 HIV-1 患者出现过敏反应(HSR)。多项研究表明人类白细胞抗原(HLA)-B5701 与阿巴卡韦的 HSR 直接相关。本研究旨在分析在接受阿巴卡韦治疗的患者中进行系统 HLA-B5701 检测以预防 HSR 是否对西班牙国家卫生系统具有成本效益。
构建了一个分析决策模型,作为 1000 名 HIV 患者模拟队列的决策树模型,以评估与不进行 HLA-B5701 检测相比,针对阿巴卡韦的 HSR 进行 HLA-B5701 检测是否具有成本效益。模型中包含的参数以及如果患者发生 HSR 使用医疗资源的情况均取自 PREDICT-1 研究和临床专家的意见。主要结果是避免每例 HSR 发生的增量成本。分析的时间范围为 2 个月。所有成本均以 2008 年欧元表示。
分析表明,每位患者的总直接医疗保健成本分别为 1344 欧元和 1322 欧元,分别进行和不进行 HLA-B*5701 检测。每 1000 名筛查患者可预防 36 例 HSR。这些结果产生了每例 HSR 避免的成本为 630 欧元。敏感性分析表明,结果对检测成本敏感,节省 102 欧元或每例 HSR 的成本效益比为 4234 欧元。
该模型预测,在 HIV+患者中开始使用阿巴卡韦之前,广泛使用 HLA-B*5701 检测可能代表国家卫生系统的经济节省或有限的额外成本,而 HSR 发生率降低则可能带来益处。