Interdepartmental Centre G. Scansetti for Studies on Asbestos and Other Toxic Particulates, University of Torino, Torino, Italy.
J Toxicol Environ Health A. 2010;73(5):368-77. doi: 10.1080/15287390903442678.
Airborne asbestos fibers are associated with many serious detrimental effects on human health, while the hazard posed by waterborne fibers remains an object of debate. In adopting a precautionary principle, asbestos content in water needs to be kept as low as possible and polluting waters with asbestos should be avoided. Turci et al. (2008) recently reported a method for the decontamination of asbestos-polluted waters or landfill leachates from chrysotile that combines power ultrasound (US) with oxalic acid (Ox), an acidic chelating molecule. In the previous study, the occurrence of antigorite, a polymorph of serpentine, the mineral group encompassing chrysotile asbestos, acted as a confounding factor for complete removal of chrysotile from water. The effects of US + Ox on pure chrysotile asbestos from Val Malenco, Italian Central Alps, were examined in this investigation. In the absence of mineral contaminants, a more rapid removal of pure chrysotile from water was undertaken with respect to the previous specimen. After only 12 h of combined US + Ox acid treatment, imaging (SEM) of mineral debris indicated complete loss of fibrous habit. In addition, crystallography and vibrational features of chrysotile were not detectable (x-ray powder diffraction [XRPD] and micro-Raman spectroscopy) and elemental analysis showed a low Mg/Si ratio, i.e., the loss of the brucitic layer in chrysotile (x-ray fluorescence, XRF). Some nanometric rod-shaped debris, observed in the previous study and tentatively recognized as serpentine antigorite, was now found to be made of amorphous silica, which is relatively safe and noncarcinogenic to humans, providing further assurance regarding the safety of treated product. Thus, data indicated the proposed method was effective in detoxifying waterborne chrysotile asbestos fibers.
空气中的石棉纤维与许多对人类健康的严重有害影响有关,而水中纤维所构成的危害仍然是一个争论的问题。在采用预防原则的情况下,水中的石棉含量需要尽可能保持在低水平,并且应该避免用石棉污染水。Turci 等人(2008 年)最近报道了一种从温石棉污染的水中或蛇纹石垃圾渗滤液中去除石棉的方法,该方法结合了超声(US)和草酸(Ox),草酸是一种酸性螯合分子。在之前的研究中,作为混杂因素,透闪石的多晶型矿物蛇纹石的存在会阻碍温石棉从水中完全去除。本研究考察了超声+Ox 对来自意大利中阿尔卑斯山瓦尔马伦科的纯温石棉的影响。在没有矿物污染物的情况下,与之前的样品相比,纯温石棉从水中的去除速度更快。经过 12 小时的联合 US+Ox 酸处理后,矿物碎片的成像(SEM)表明完全失去了纤维形态。此外,温石棉的结晶学和振动特征无法检测到(X 射线粉末衍射[XRPD]和微拉曼光谱),元素分析显示 Mg/Si 比值低,即温石棉中的镁层丢失(X 射线荧光,XRF)。在前一项研究中观察到的一些纳米级棒状碎片,被推测为蛇纹石纤蛇纹石,现在被发现由无定形二氧化硅组成,对人类相对安全且无致癌性,这进一步保证了处理产品的安全性。因此,数据表明,所提出的方法在水基温石棉纤维解毒方面是有效的。