Molven Olav
Statens helsetilsyn, Postboks 8128 Dep, 0032 Oslo og Diakonhjemmet høgskole Oslo, Norway.
Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen. 2010 Feb 11;130(3):266-9. doi: 10.4045/tidsskr.09.0694.
When health care leads to serious adverse events that result in (or could have resulted in) injuries to patients, hospitals are obliged to report this to The Norwegian Board of Health Supervision in the Counties. The purpose of this study was to quantify how many cases were instigated on the basis of reports sent to the supervisory authority and to what extent health personnel were sanctioned because of them.
Reports received by The Norwegian Board of Health Supervision in the Counties (in the period 1.07.2002- 30.06.2007) and cases instigated by the National Board of Health (on basis of the reports) in the period 1.01.2003-31.12.2007.
The supervisory authority received 9268 reports in the period. 443 (4.7 %) of them led to instigation of cases and 19 of these (2 of the reports) resulted in formal sanctioning of health personnel (13 of the sanctions were to physicians; 12 received a warning and one lost her specialist license). The Board of Health Supervision seems to have quite different thresholds for instigating report-based cases in the various counties.
Health personnel seem to have little reason to fear that reports on (potential) adverse events will lead to sanctions from the supervisory authority. However, the Board of Health Supervision in the Counties should have a more predictable practice concerning instigation of report-based cases.
当医疗保健导致严重不良事件并致使患者受伤(或本可导致患者受伤)时,医院有义务向各郡的挪威卫生监督局报告此类事件。本研究的目的是量化基于提交给监督机构的报告而引发的案例数量,以及卫生人员因这些报告而受到制裁的程度。
各郡的挪威卫生监督局收到的报告(2002年7月1日至2007年6月30日期间)以及国家卫生局基于这些报告引发的案例(2003年1月1日至2007年12月31日期间)。
在此期间,监督机构共收到9268份报告。其中443份(4.7%)报告引发了案例,其中19份(2份报告)导致卫生人员受到正式制裁(13份制裁针对医生;12人收到警告,1人被吊销专科医生执照)。卫生监督局在各郡基于报告引发案例的阈值似乎差异很大。
卫生人员似乎没有什么理由担心关于(潜在)不良事件的报告会导致监督机构的制裁。然而,各郡的卫生监督局在基于报告引发案例方面应有更可预测的做法。