O'Sullivan G, Noshirvani H, Marks I, Monteiro W, Lelliott P
Department of Experimental Psychopathology, Institute of Psychiatry, London, United Kingdom.
J Clin Psychiatry. 1991 Apr;52(4):150-5.
To determine whether gains from exposure therapy are lasting in patients with chronic obsessive compulsive disorder, the authors followed up 34 (85%) of 40 such patients who had been treated 6 years earlier with exposure therapy for 3 or 6 weeks and with clomipramine or placebo for 36 weeks. Severity of obsessive compulsive disorder was assessed by rating the discomfort caused by the time devoted to four target rituals, the Behavioral Avoidance Test, and the Compulsion Checklist. Mood was assessed by the 17-item Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression, the Wakefield Self-Assessment Depression Inventory, and the Anxiety scale. In addition, the patients' general adjustment was assessed. The authors found that the group as a whole remained significantly improved on obsessive compulsive symptoms, work and social adjustment, and depression; however, the group returned to pretreatment levels (slight to moderate) of general anxiety. They found that neither clomipramine nor placebo affected long-term outcome and that the majority of patients who were taking clomipramine or other antidepressants at follow-up were no more improved that those who were not taking antidepressants. Better long-term outcome correlated with more exposure therapy (6 weeks of therapy vs. 3 weeks) and with better compliance with the exposure therapy homework. The best predictor of long-term outcome was improvement at the end of treatment. Subjects who had initially been most depressed were more likely to receive psychotropic medication during follow-up. Initial severity of illness did not preclude benefit from exposure therapy.
为了确定暴露疗法对慢性强迫症患者的疗效是否持久,作者对40例此类患者中的34例(85%)进行了随访,这些患者在6年前接受了为期3周或6周的暴露疗法,并同时服用氯米帕明或安慰剂36周。通过对专注于四项目标仪式所花费时间引起的不适、行为回避测试和强迫检查表来评估强迫症的严重程度。通过17项汉密尔顿抑郁评定量表、韦克菲尔德自我评估抑郁量表和焦虑量表来评估情绪。此外,还对患者的总体适应情况进行了评估。作者发现,总体而言,该组患者在强迫症症状、工作和社交适应以及抑郁方面仍有显著改善;然而,该组患者的总体焦虑水平恢复到了治疗前(轻度至中度)的水平。他们发现,氯米帕明和安慰剂均未影响长期疗效,且随访时服用氯米帕明或其他抗抑郁药的大多数患者并不比未服用抗抑郁药的患者改善得更多。更好的长期疗效与更多的暴露疗法(6周治疗与3周治疗)以及更好地完成暴露疗法家庭作业相关。长期疗效的最佳预测指标是治疗结束时的改善情况。最初抑郁程度最重的受试者在随访期间更有可能接受精神药物治疗。疾病的初始严重程度并不妨碍从暴露疗法中获益。