Heart of Birmingham tPCT, 142 Hagley Rd., Birmingham B16 9PA, UK.
J Tissue Viability. 2010 Feb;19(1):16-21. doi: 10.1016/j.jtv.2010.01.002.
Despite practical advantages (such as exudate management and reduced dressing changes) the adoption of topical negative pressure therapy (TNP) in home care may be restricted through logistical issues and a perception that the intervention is more expensive than the more traditionally utilised wound management products. This pilot study followed the experiences of 20 subjects with a variety of acute and chronic wounds who received TNP either in hospital (n=10), at home (n=5) or in both care settings (n=5). All except one subject showed both reductions in wound surface area and improved appearance of the wound bed during the course of treatment ranging from 2 to 74 days. The single subject, where a deterioration in their wound was noted, had presented with an unclear wound diagnosis thus highlighting the absolute need for accurate diagnosis of wound aetiology prior to commencement of any treatment regime. The cost of treatment was lower where subjects were treated at home (mean cost per day pound45.9 SD: 17.0) and highest where care was delivered exclusively in hospital (mean cost per day pound259.1 SD: 2.8). Direct comparison of these data with other published studies on the use of TNP therapies is obviously restricted through regional differences in the cost of nursing care, patterns of use of the TNP consumables and the wound outcomes followed in individual cases, however, there would appear to be a qualitative and economic benefit from home care.
尽管局部负压疗法(TNP)具有实际优势(如渗出液管理和减少换药次数),但其在家庭护理中的应用可能会受到后勤问题的限制,并且人们认为这种干预比传统的伤口管理产品更昂贵。这项初步研究随访了 20 名患有各种急性和慢性伤口的受试者的治疗经验,他们分别在医院(n=10)、家庭(n=5)或两种护理环境中(n=5)接受 TNP 治疗。除了一名受试者外,所有受试者的伤口面积都有所缩小,伤口床的外观也有所改善,治疗时间从 2 天到 74 天不等。唯一一名伤口恶化的受试者的伤口诊断不明确,这突出表明在开始任何治疗方案之前,绝对需要准确诊断伤口病因。在家庭中接受治疗的受试者(每天治疗费用为 45.9 英镑,标准差为 17.0)的治疗费用较低,而在医院中接受专门护理的受试者(每天治疗费用为 259.1 英镑,标准差为 2.8)的治疗费用最高。由于护理费用、TNP 耗材使用模式以及在个别病例中跟踪的伤口结局在不同地区存在差异,因此这些数据与其他关于 TNP 治疗应用的已发表研究的直接比较显然受到限制,但从家庭护理中似乎可以获得定性和经济效益。