Weir Ian D, Drescher Frank, Cousin Daniel, Fraser Ezra T, Lee Ronald, Berman Lewis, Strauss Edward, Wang Yun, Fine Jonathan M
Norwalk Hospital, Section of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, USA.
Conn Med. 2010 Jan;74(1):5-9.
We hypothesize that the ready availability of chest computed tomography (CT) scan, with angiography (CTA), for pulmonary embolism (PE) has resulted in its increased use in the emergency department (ED) with an associated decrease in positive studies.
CTA for diagnosis of PE increased over 13-fold from 2000 to 2005. The diagnostic yield of CTA for PE decreased from 14% in 2000 to a mean (SD) of 7.2 (.91)% during subsequent years (P =.007). No significant change in yield occurred after 2001 (P = 0.51). Significantly more segmental and subsegmental embolisms were observed with the 16-slice CT in years 2004-2005 when compared to the single-slice CT used in years 2000-2003.
CTA for PE in our hospital ED has a low-positive yield rate, suggesting overutilization. However, the positive-yield rate remained steady despite increasing numbers of CTA, suggesting increased detection of PE and/or false-positive CTA.
我们推测,胸部计算机断层扫描(CT)联合血管造影(CTA)用于诊断肺栓塞(PE)在急诊科的广泛应用,导致其使用量增加,同时阳性检查结果减少。
从2000年到2005年,用于诊断PE的CTA增加了13倍多。CTA对PE的诊断率从2000年的14%降至随后几年的平均(标准差)7.2(0.91)%(P = 0.007)。2001年后诊断率无显著变化(P = 0.51)。与2000 - 2003年使用的单层CT相比,2004 - 2005年使用16层CT观察到的节段性和亚节段性栓塞明显更多。
我院急诊科用于PE的CTA阳性率较低,提示存在过度使用情况。然而,尽管CTA数量增加,但阳性率保持稳定,提示PE检测增加和/或CTA出现假阳性。