Dep. of Animal Science, University of Nebraska, Lincoln, NE, USA.
J Environ Qual. 2010 Feb 19;39(2):472-82. doi: 10.2134/jeq2009.0283. Print 2010 Mar-Apr.
Environmental regulations on greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from corn (Zea mays L.)-ethanol production require accurate assessment methods to determine emissions savings from coproducts that are fed to livestock. We investigated current use of coproducts in livestock diets and estimated the magnitude and variability in the GHG emissions credit for coproducts in the corn-ethanol life cycle. The coproduct GHG emissions credit varied by more than twofold, from 11.5 to 28.3 g CO(2)e per MJ of ethanol produced, depending on the fraction of coproducts used without drying, the proportion of coproduct used to feed beef cattle (Bos taurus) vs. dairy or swine (Sus scrofa), and the location of corn production. Regional variability in the GHG intensity of crop production and future livestock feeding trends will determine the magnitude of the coproduct GHG offset against GHG emissions elsewhere in the corn-ethanol life cycle. Expansion of annual U.S. corn-ethanol production to 57 billion liters by 2015, as mandated in current federal law, will require feeding of coproduct at inclusion levels near the biological limit to the entire U.S. feedlot cattle, dairy, and swine herds. Under this future scenario, the coproduct GHG offset will decrease by 8% from current levels due to expanded use by dairy and swine, which are less efficient in use of coproduct than beef feedlot cattle. Because the coproduct GHG credit represents 19 to 38% of total life cycle GHG emissions, accurate estimation of the coproduct credit is important for determining the net impact of corn-ethanol production on atmospheric warming and whether corn-ethanol producers meet state- and national-level GHG emissions regulations.
环境法规对玉米(Zea mays L.)-乙醇生产的温室气体(GHG)排放有要求,需要采用准确的评估方法来确定用于饲养牲畜的副产物的减排量。我们研究了当前在牲畜饲料中使用副产物的情况,并估计了玉米-乙醇生命周期中副产物的 GHG 排放信用的幅度和可变性。副产物的 GHG 排放信用差异超过两倍,从生产每兆焦耳乙醇的 11.5 到 28.3 克二氧化碳当量不等,具体取决于未干燥使用的副产物部分、用于饲养肉牛(Bos taurus)、奶牛或猪(Sus scrofa)的副产物比例,以及玉米生产的地点。作物生产的 GHG 强度的区域差异和未来牲畜饲养趋势将决定玉米-乙醇生命周期中其他地方的 GHG 排放与副产物 GHG 抵消的幅度。如现行联邦法律规定,到 2015 年,美国的玉米-乙醇年生产将扩大到 570 亿升,这将需要在接近生物极限的水平下用副产物来饲养美国所有的牛、奶牛和猪。在这种未来情景下,由于奶牛和猪的使用增加,副产物的 GHG 抵消将比目前减少 8%,因为它们对副产物的利用效率低于肉牛饲养场。由于副产物的 GHG 信用额占总生命周期 GHG 排放的 19%至 38%,因此准确估计副产物信用额对于确定玉米-乙醇生产对大气变暖的净影响以及玉米-乙醇生产商是否符合州和国家一级的 GHG 排放法规非常重要。