Chazan J A, Libbey N P, London M R, Pono L, Abuelo J G
Department of Medicine, Rhode Island Hospital, Providence 02903.
Clin Nephrol. 1991 Feb;35(2):78-85.
Fifty-nine chronic hemodialysis patients who had been on dialysis for an average of 77 months underwent bone biopsies and the pathologic findings were correlated with biochemical and demographic data. All but two had evidence of renal osteodystrophy, 23 with osteitis fibrosa (OF), 19 with osteomalacia and/or adynamic disease (OM/AD), and 15 with mixed osteodystrophy (MOD). Patients in each group were similar with regard to age, sex distribution, duration of dialysis, unstimulated serum aluminum, calcium and phosphorus. Patients with osteitis fibrosa (OF) had statistically higher DFO stimulated aluminum, alkaline phosphatase and PTHC levels than the other two groups although there was marked individual variation. The bone biopsies were also evaluated for the amount of aluminum deposited in the osteoid seam. All 23 of the patients with OF and 11 of the 15 patients with MOD had no, mild, or minimal aluminum deposition but 12 of the 19 patients with OM/AD had moderate to marked aluminum deposition. Patients with minimal to mild aluminum deposition were similar in age, duration of dialysis, sex distribution, unstimulated and DFO stimulated aluminum levels, calcium, phosphorus, alkaline phosphatase to those with moderate to marked deposition but had significantly higher parathormone levels. All patients had been treated in a similar fashion regarding diet, oral phosphate binders and vitamin D; therefore, the observed differences in bone pathology were not readily explicable. However, patients who were found to have osteitis fibrosa and those with minimal to mild aluminum deposition had significantly higher parathormone levels when compared with patients in the other groups at the inception of dialysis.
59名平均透析77个月的慢性血液透析患者接受了骨活检,病理结果与生化和人口统计学数据相关。除两名患者外,所有患者均有肾性骨营养不良的证据,其中23例为纤维性骨炎(OF),19例为骨软化症和/或动力缺乏性骨病(OM/AD),15例为混合性骨营养不良(MOD)。每组患者在年龄、性别分布、透析时间、未刺激血清铝、钙和磷方面相似。纤维性骨炎(OF)患者的去铁胺刺激铝、碱性磷酸酶和全段甲状旁腺激素(PTHC)水平在统计学上高于其他两组,尽管存在明显的个体差异。还对骨活检标本评估类骨质缝中铝的沉积量。所有23例OF患者和15例MOD患者中的11例没有、仅有轻度或极少铝沉积,但19例OM/AD患者中有12例有中度至明显的铝沉积。铝沉积极少至轻度的患者在年龄、透析时间、性别分布、未刺激和去铁胺刺激的铝水平、钙、磷、碱性磷酸酶方面与中度至明显沉积的患者相似,但甲状旁腺激素水平显著更高。所有患者在饮食、口服磷结合剂和维生素D治疗方面方式相似;因此观察到的骨病理差异难以轻易解释。然而,与透析开始时其他组的患者相比,被发现有纤维性骨炎的患者以及铝沉积极少至轻度的患者甲状旁腺激素水平显著更高。