Department of Medical Intensive Care, European Hospital Georges Pompidou, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Université Paris-Descartes, France.
Am J Crit Care. 2010 Mar;19(2):135-45; quiz 146. doi: 10.4037/ajcc2010590.
Morbidity and mortality conferences are a tool for evaluating care management, but they lack a precise format for practice in intensive care units.
To evaluate the feasibility and usefulness of regular morbidity and mortality conferences specific to intensive care units for improving quality of care and patient safety.
For 1 year, a prospective study was conducted in an 18-bed intensive care unit. Events analyzed included deaths in the unit and 4 adverse events (unexpected cardiac arrest, unplanned extubation, reintubation within 24-48 hours after planned extubation, and readmission to the unit within 48 hours after discharge) considered potentially preventable in optimal intensive care practice. During conferences, events were collectively analyzed with the help of an external auditor to determine their severity, causality, and preventability.
During the study period, 260 deaths and 100 adverse events involving 300 patients were analyzed. The adverse events rate was 16.6 per 1000 patient-days. Adverse events occurred more often between noon and 4 pm (P = .001).The conference consensus was that 6.1% of deaths and 36% of adverse events were preventable. Preventable deaths were associated with iatrogenesis (P = .008), human errors (P < .001), and failure of unit management factors or communication (P = .003). Three major recommendations were made concerning standardization of care or prescription and organizational management, and no similar incidents have recurred.
In addition to their educational value, regular morbidity and mortality conferences formatted for intensive care units are useful for assessing quality of care and patient safety.
发病率和死亡率会议是评估医疗管理的一种工具,但它们缺乏针对重症监护病房的实践的精确格式。
评估针对重症监护病房的定期发病率和死亡率会议在改善护理质量和患者安全方面的可行性和实用性。
在一个 18 张床的重症监护病房进行了为期 1 年的前瞻性研究。分析的事件包括该病房的死亡和 4 种不良事件(意外心脏骤停、计划拔管后意外拔管、计划拔管后 24-48 小时内重新插管和出院后 48 小时内再次入住病房),这些事件被认为在最佳重症监护实践中是可以预防的。在会议上,借助外部审核员对事件进行集体分析,以确定其严重程度、因果关系和可预防程度。
在研究期间,分析了涉及 300 名患者的 260 例死亡和 100 例不良事件。不良事件发生率为每 1000 患者天 16.6 例。不良事件更多发生在中午至下午 4 点之间(P=.001)。会议达成的共识是,6.1%的死亡和 36%的不良事件是可以预防的。可预防的死亡与医源性疾病(P=.008)、人为错误(P <.001)以及单位管理因素或沟通失败(P=.003)有关。针对护理或处方的标准化以及组织管理提出了 3 项主要建议,此后未再发生类似事件。
除了具有教育价值外,针对重症监护病房制定的定期发病率和死亡率会议对于评估护理质量和患者安全也很有用。