Dobbels F, Ruppar T, De Geest S, Decorte A, Van Damme-Lombaerts R, Fine R N
Center for Health Services and Nursing Research, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium.
Pediatr Transplant. 2010 Aug;14(5):603-13. doi: 10.1111/j.1399-3046.2010.01299.x. Epub 2010 Feb 28.
As most prior reviews on NA focus on adult transplant patients, there is a need for a comprehensive overview on adherence to the immunosuppressive regimen in pediatric kidney transplant patients. This systematic review searched for English-language papers (1990-2008) addressing the prevalence of NA to the immunosuppressive regimen, its consequences, determinants, and interventions in pediatric kidney transplant patients (< age 21 yr). We found 36 papers, showing a prevalence of NA (weighted mean) of 31.8% with adolescents being more at risk compared to younger patients. About 44% of all graft losses and 23% of late acute rejection episodes are associated with NA. Most studies investigated socio-economic, condition-related or treatment-related determinants. Only one educational intervention has been tested but yielded inconclusive results. NA to the immunosuppressive regimen is prevalent with serious clinical consequences in pediatric kidney transplant patients, but the economic consequences have not yet been explored. More studies on determinants of NA are needed. The literature currently lacks fully powered RCTs testing adherence-enhancing interventions. The results of this systematic review identify the gaps in the present evidence-based information regarding NA and can be used as a tool to pursue future adherence research in pediatric populations.
由于以往大多数关于不依从性(NA)的综述都聚焦于成年移植患者,因此有必要对小儿肾移植患者免疫抑制方案的依从性进行全面概述。本系统综述检索了1990年至2008年期间涉及小儿肾移植患者(年龄<21岁)对免疫抑制方案的不依从性患病率、其后果、决定因素及干预措施的英文文献。我们找到了36篇论文,显示不依从性(加权均值)患病率为31.8%,青少年比年幼患者面临的风险更高。所有移植失败病例中约44%以及晚期急性排斥反应发作病例中23%与不依从性有关。大多数研究调查了社会经济、病情相关或治疗相关的决定因素。仅一项教育干预措施经过测试,但结果尚无定论。小儿肾移植患者中对免疫抑制方案的不依从性普遍存在且具有严重临床后果,但经济后果尚未得到探讨。需要开展更多关于不依从性决定因素的研究。目前文献中缺乏充分有力的随机对照试验来测试增强依从性的干预措施。本系统综述的结果明确了当前关于不依从性的循证信息中的差距,可作为开展未来小儿人群依从性研究的工具。