Department of Surgery, University of Bonn Medical Centre, Sigmund-Freud-Strasse 25, Bonn, Germany.
Langenbecks Arch Surg. 2010 Apr;395 Suppl 1:23-6. doi: 10.1007/s00423-010-0616-3. Epub 2010 Mar 9.
At the end of the nineteenth century, three prominent German surgical journals (i.e., "Deutsche Zeitschrift für Chirurgie," "Bruns' Beiträge," and "Langenbeck's Archiv für Klinische Chirurgie") dominated the surgical academic scene in Germany. While written exclusively in German, these publications were widely read in Germany as well as abroad. Today, only the oldest of these journals, Langenbeck's Archiv, remains. In 1913, the "Zentralorgan für die gesamte Chirurgie" was instituted in Germany as a separate publication specifically dedicated to improve the communication of foreign scientific contributions. However, on a number of occasions, landmark papers from outside the country were not fully appreciated by the German readership, just as nowadays, key surgical papers published in German are only infrequently acknowledged in the Anglo-American scientific literature. At all times, innovative scientific works had a difficult time finding open ears and minds if they challenged long-held academic preconceptions. It appeared hard to question dogmas that readers had believed to be true for so long. After 1945, German surgery found itself eclipsed in many areas by new developments in the anglophone surgical communities since the academic exchange of ideas had been largely curtailed for more than a decade. English-speaking surgeons were more numerous, and the flow of communication became easier and more and more rapid.
Over time, the entire field of surgery in Germany began to emulate what had proven so effective in the English-speaking world. Langenbeck's Archiv is now published in English.
在 19 世纪末,三份杰出的德国外科期刊(即“Deutsche Zeitschrift für Chirurgie”、“Bruns' Beiträge”和“Langenbeck's Archiv für Klinische Chirurgie”)主导了德国的外科学术领域。尽管这些出版物均为德文撰写,但在德国乃至国外都有广泛的读者群。如今,只有这些期刊中最古老的一份——Langenbeck's Archiv 仍在继续出版。1913 年,“Zentralorgan für die gesamte Chirurgie”在德国作为一份专门用于改善国外科学贡献交流的独立出版物成立。然而,在许多情况下,来自国外的重要论文并没有被德国读者充分理解,就像现在,在德国发表的重要外科论文在英美学术文献中也很少被承认。任何时候,如果创新的科学作品挑战了长期存在的学术偏见,它们都很难找到开放的耳朵和思维。似乎很难质疑读者长期以来一直认为正确的教条。1945 年后,由于学术思想交流在十多年的时间里基本中断,德国外科在许多领域被英语国家的外科社区的新发展所掩盖。英语国家的外科医生数量更多,交流变得更加容易和迅速。
随着时间的推移,德国整个外科领域开始效仿在英语世界中被证明非常有效的方法。Langenbeck's Archiv 现在以英文出版。