Severi S, Michelassi C
CNR Clinical Physiology Institute, Pisa, Italy.
Circulation. 1991 May;83(5 Suppl):III82-8.
Observational data prospectively collected permit the examination of a complex set of decisions, including the decision not to perform any stress testing. Patients with or without previous myocardial infarction admitted for coronary evaluation and not submitted to any stress testing because of clinical reasons are at a higher risk for subsequent death. For prognostication, no test has been better validated than exercise electrocardiography: it can identify patients at low and high risk for future cardiac events among those without symptoms, with typical chest pain, and with previous myocardial infarction. In patients with triple-vessel disease, the results of exercise also allow those at low and high risk to be recognized. Both exercise radionuclide angiography and 201Tl scintigraphy (the latter in larger patient populations) have also demonstrated significant prognostic value on patients with or without previous myocardial infarction. Neither one has shown superiority to the other in prognostication. So far, they have been considered the only viable alternatives to exercise electrocardiography stress testing for diagnosis and prognostication. However, their costs limit their extensive application. Preliminary data suggest that intravenous dipyridamole echocardiography can be used for both diagnosis and prognostication of coronary artery disease; moreover, the prognostic information derived from dipyridamole echocardiography testing seems independent of and additive to that provided by exercise electrocardiography. Further prospective studies on larger patient populations are needed to better define the prognostic value of dipyridamole echocardiography testing.
前瞻性收集的观察数据有助于考察一系列复杂的决策,包括不进行任何负荷试验的决策。因临床原因入院接受冠脉评估且未进行任何负荷试验的患者,无论有无既往心肌梗死,后续死亡风险均较高。就预后评估而言,没有哪种检查比运动心电图得到了更好的验证:它能够在无症状、有典型胸痛以及有既往心肌梗死的患者中识别出未来发生心脏事件风险低和高的患者。在三支血管病变患者中,运动结果也能识别出风险低和高的患者。运动放射性核素血管造影和201铊闪烁扫描(后者应用于更多患者群体)对有或无既往心肌梗死的患者也显示出显著的预后价值。在预后评估方面,两者均未显示出优于对方。到目前为止,它们一直被认为是运动心电图负荷试验用于诊断和预后评估的唯一可行替代方法。然而,其成本限制了它们的广泛应用。初步数据表明,静脉注射双嘧达莫超声心动图可用于冠心病的诊断和预后评估;此外,双嘧达莫超声心动图检查得出的预后信息似乎独立于运动心电图提供的信息且与之互补。需要对更多患者群体进行进一步的前瞻性研究,以更好地确定双嘧达莫超声心动图检查的预后价值。