Bourgeois P, Malarme M, Van Franck R, Wauters G, Ferremans W
C.H.J. Bracops, Department of Nuclear Medicine, Université Libre de Bruxelles, Belgium.
Nucl Med Commun. 1991 Jan;12(1):35-45. doi: 10.1097/00006231-199101000-00005.
Bone marrow scintigrams (MS) were performed on 73 men with histologically proven prostatic carcinomas. Follow-up data were available in 24 cases. Thirty-six patients had skeletal metastases at the time of the first MS investigation. They were compared with conventional bone scintigrams (BS) as well as clinical, biological, radiological and other follow-up data obtained for the same patients. At the present stage of revision and of follow-up of our patients, MS appeared less sensitive than BS in diagnosing skeletal metastases (94% as against 100% if all abnormal MS and BS presentations are considered as diagnostic or 83% as against 86% if more restrictive analytic criteria were applied). On the other hand, MS showed slightly higher specificity (81% for MS as against 73% for BS) when all abnormal MS and BS presentations are considered as diagnostic. With more restrictive diagnostic criteria, BS remains more specific (100%) than MS (87%). Nevertheless, the likelihood of bone metastasis is low when a normal MS is found in case of dubious BS situations, but high when the MS is pathological. In 11 patients with skeletal metastasis for whom follow-up investigations were available, MS appeared better than (4 cases) or equivalent to (6 cases) BS for evaluating the responses and the ultimate evolution of the disease. Marrow scintigrams are thus a useful tool in cases of dubious BS and for evaluating the response of skeletal metastasis to treatment.
对73名经组织学证实患有前列腺癌的男性进行了骨髓闪烁扫描(MS)。24例患者有随访数据。在首次MS检查时,36例患者有骨转移。将他们与传统骨闪烁扫描(BS)以及同一患者的临床、生物学、放射学和其他随访数据进行比较。在我们患者目前的复查和随访阶段,MS在诊断骨转移方面似乎不如BS敏感(如果将所有异常的MS和BS表现都视为诊断性的,则分别为94%和100%;如果应用更严格的分析标准,则分别为83%和86%)。另一方面,当将所有异常的MS和BS表现都视为诊断性的时,MS的特异性略高(MS为81%,BS为73%)。采用更严格的诊断标准时,BS的特异性(100%)仍高于MS(87%)。然而,在BS结果可疑的情况下,如果MS正常,则骨转移的可能性较低,但如果MS异常,则可能性较高。在11例有骨转移且有随访调查的患者中,在评估疾病的反应和最终进展方面,MS表现优于BS(4例)或与BS相当(6例)。因此,骨髓闪烁扫描在BS结果可疑的情况下以及评估骨转移对治疗的反应方面是一种有用的工具。