Aubry P, Assayag P, Faraggi M, Haddad A, Akesbi A, Messian O, Brochet E, Bok B, Valère P E
Service de Cardiologie, CHU Beaujon, Clichy.
Ann Cardiol Angeiol (Paris). 1991 Jan;40(1):9-13.
The detection of coronary disease before valve surgery remains difficult in the absence of coronary arteriography. The contribution of myocardial scintigraphy with dipyridamole (MS-DP) was studied in 34 consecutive patients with valve disease (11 mitral and 23 aortic) with a mean age of 63 +/- 11 years having undergone coronary arteriography before valve surgery. Coronary arteriography was performed because of angina (21 cases) or age (women greater than 50, men greater than 40). Positive criteria of coronary disease were the presence of at least one frank and clearly visible fault of myocardial perfusion (MS-DP positive) and at least one stenosis of greater than 70 per cent by coronary arteriography. Coronary disease existed in 13 patients (38 per cent). Ten patients (29 per cent) had a positive MS-DP. The sensitivity and specificity of MS-DP in detecting coronary disease were 69 per cent and 95 per cent respectively. Its positive predictive value was 90 per cent. MS-DP was negative in all asymptomatic patients (19 per cent of them having coronary disease) and in 11 symptomatic patients (18 per cent of them having coronary disease). The low positive predictive value of angina (52 per cent) increased to 90 per cent when combined with a positive MS-DP. Because of relatively low sensitivity, basing indications for coronary arteriography before valve surgery on the results of MS-DP cannot be advised.
在没有冠状动脉造影的情况下,瓣膜手术前冠心病的检测仍然很困难。对34例连续的瓣膜病患者(11例二尖瓣病变和23例主动脉瓣病变)进行了双嘧达莫心肌闪烁显像(MS-DP)的研究,这些患者平均年龄为63±11岁,在瓣膜手术前均接受了冠状动脉造影。进行冠状动脉造影的原因是心绞痛(21例)或年龄(女性大于50岁,男性大于40岁)。冠心病的阳性标准是存在至少一处明显且清晰可见的心肌灌注缺陷(MS-DP阳性)以及冠状动脉造影显示至少一处狭窄大于70%。13例患者(38%)存在冠心病。10例患者(29%)MS-DP呈阳性。MS-DP检测冠心病的敏感性和特异性分别为69%和95%。其阳性预测值为90%。所有无症状患者(其中19%患有冠心病)和11例有症状患者(其中18%患有冠心病)的MS-DP均为阴性。心绞痛的低阳性预测值(52%)在与MS-DP阳性相结合时升至90%。由于敏感性相对较低,不建议根据MS-DP的结果来确定瓣膜手术前冠状动脉造影的指征。