Li Shao, Zhang Ning-bo, Li Zhi-hong
Department of Automation, Tsinghua University, Beijing.
Zhongguo Zhong Xi Yi Jie He Za Zhi. 2009 Nov;29(11):993-6.
To establish a clinical data based practical diagnostic model for Chinese medicine syndrome differentiation in patients with chronic hepatitis B (CHB), by way of seeking a combination of symptoms, signs and laboratory criteria associated with the typical syndromes of the disease.
A syndromatologic and laboratory investigation on 88 symptoms, 20 signs, and 14 laboratory indexes, was conducted in 1004 CHB patients. The clinical data of typical syndromes were selected and analyzed using Logistic regression analysis, decision tree and Bayesian network analysis in combination to establish a diagnostic model for effectively identifying the typical syndromes in CHB.
The most typical syndromes revealed in the 1004 CHB patients were the Gan-dan damp-heat syndrome (340 patients, accounting for 33.86%) and the Gan-stagnancy with Pi-deficiency syndrome (366 patients, 36.45%). Based on the clinical data from patients with the two syndromes, 16 symptoms/signs and 3 laboratory indicators, provided with statistical significance, were selected using Logistic regression analysis. Then, a diagnostic model for differential the two syndromes, which was proved to have an accurate diagnosic rate of 74.36%, was formed by decision tree method. It was found that white tongue coating, light red tongue, yellow sclera, eye dryness, blood levels of alanine aminotransferase and HBeAg appeared to be the effective combination of indexes that may be helpful to differentiate the two syndromes. And the significance of the above-mentioned indexes was also verified by a Bayesian network approach.
A decision tree model for diagnosing the two typical syndromes in CHB patients, the Gan-dan damp-heat syndrome and the Gan-stagnancy with Pi-deficiency syndrome, was established, which could be helpful for shifting the diagnosis of syndrome from experience-based to the data-model-based form, to make the syndrome diagnosis more objectively.
通过寻找与慢性乙型肝炎(CHB)典型证候相关的症状、体征及实验室指标的组合,建立基于临床数据的CHB中医证候实用诊断模型。
对1004例CHB患者进行了关于88项症状、20项体征及14项实验室指标的证候学及实验室调查。选取典型证候的临床数据,联合运用Logistic回归分析、决策树及贝叶斯网络分析进行筛选与分析,建立能有效识别CHB典型证候的诊断模型。
1004例CHB患者中最典型的证候为肝胆湿热证(340例,占33.86%)和肝郁脾虚证(366例,占36.45%)。基于两证型患者的临床数据,经Logistic回归分析筛选出具有统计学意义的16项症状/体征及3项实验室指标。然后,采用决策树方法构建了两证型的鉴别诊断模型,经检验其诊断准确率为74.36%。发现白苔、舌淡红、巩膜黄染、眼干、丙氨酸氨基转移酶及HBeAg水平是有助于鉴别两证型的有效指标组合。上述指标的意义也通过贝叶斯网络方法得到验证。
建立了CHB患者肝胆湿热证和肝郁脾虚证这两种典型证候的决策树诊断模型,有助于将证候诊断从经验型转变为数据模型型,使证候诊断更客观。