Teculescu D, Racineux J L
INSERM Unité 115, Faculté de Médecine, Vandoeuvre.
Rev Mal Respir. 1991;8(1):29-37.
The change in maximal expiratory flows after inhalation of gases of various physical properties is studied since 1963. The Montreal team proposed in 1972 the helium-to-air difference in maximal expiratory flows at low lung volumes (delta He) and the volume at which the flows breathing air and the helium-oxygen mixture (the "volume isoflow" - Viso V) as "sensitive tests" for the detection of peripheral airway obstruction. "Density-dependence" (DD) has been widely used subsequently in the study of the site of bronchial obstruction in asthmatics in smokers, in subjects with early chronic bronchitis, subjects with occupational exposures to respiratory irritants, etc. The site of action of bronchodilators according to their nature or route of administration (atropine derivates acting on "central airways", "global" bronchodilation obtained by parenteral administration) was studied using DD. However, the interpretation of these studies was always based on Mead's "equal pressure point" concept minimizing the role played by bronchial wall compliance as put forward by Pride and coll. (1967). The results of certain experimental or clinical studies was found not to agree with the original explanations. Finally, the model of flow limitation recently described by Dawson and Elliott (1977) takes into account gas density and bronchial wall elasticity which determine the speed of waves propagating against flow in elastic tubes, the site of "choke points" and the cross-sectional airway area at this level. Besides methodological problems, the complex nature of mechanisms controlling bronchial flow with gases of different densities and the unavoidable influence of bronchodilators or bronchial wall compliance are major limiting factors for the use of DD in the study of the site of airflow obstruction, and effect of bronchodilator action.
自1963年起,人们就开始研究吸入不同物理性质的气体后最大呼气流量的变化。1972年,蒙特利尔团队提出将低肺容积时最大呼气流量的氦气与空气差值(δHe)以及呼吸空气和氦氧混合气时流量相等的容积(“等流量容积”-Viso V)作为检测外周气道阻塞的“敏感试验”。随后,“密度依赖性”(DD)被广泛应用于研究哮喘患者、吸烟者、早期慢性支气管炎患者、职业性接触呼吸道刺激物者等的支气管阻塞部位。利用DD研究了根据其性质或给药途径的支气管扩张剂的作用部位(作用于“中央气道”的阿托品衍生物,通过胃肠外给药获得“全面”的支气管扩张)。然而,这些研究的解释始终基于米德的“等压点”概念,而忽视了普赖德等人(1967年)提出的支气管壁顺应性所起的作用。发现某些实验或临床研究结果与最初的解释不一致。最后,道森和埃利奥特(1977年)最近描述的流量限制模型考虑了气体密度和支气管壁弹性,这两者决定了弹性管中逆气流传播的波速、“阻塞点”的位置以及该水平的气道横截面积。除了方法学问题外,控制不同密度气体支气管流量的机制的复杂性以及支气管扩张剂或支气管壁顺应性不可避免的影响是DD在气流阻塞部位研究和支气管扩张剂作用效果研究中应用的主要限制因素。