Child Neurology, Paediatric Department, I Faculty of Medicine, Sapienza University, c/o Policlinico Umberto I, Rome, Italy.
J Headache Pain. 2010 Jun;11(3):267-76. doi: 10.1007/s10194-010-0205-4. Epub 2010 Mar 27.
There is a serious lack of controlled studies on the pharmacological treatment of primary migraine in the developmental age; there is, consequently, an urgent need for new, evidence-based approaches to this long-neglected field of research. Moreover, previous studies have stated that the placebo response is greater in pediatric patients than in adults and that a reduction in the attack frequency in the absence of any pharmacological treatment is observed more frequently in pediatric migraine patients than in adults. Besides these preliminary considerations, the shorter duration of migraine attacks and other characteristic semeiological features of the clinical picture in children are such that the design of randomized controlled trial (RCT) is more problematic in the developmental age than in the adult. Bearing in mind all these weak points, the aim of this review was to summarize and update recent guidelines for the treatment of primary migraine in children and adolescents. The most recent guidelines are those published by the Italian Society for the study of Headache, the French Society for the study of Migraine and Headache, and the American Academy of Neurology. We have incorporated into these guidelines the results from the few, recent RCTs, clinical controlled trials, open-label studies, meta-analyses and reviews that have been published since 2004; owing to the lack of strong evidence in this field of research, we have sometimes even mentioned pilot non-controlled studies, case series and expert opinions. Lastly, evidence was classified and the recommendations were categorized according to different levels.
在儿童发育期,原发性偏头痛的药物治疗的对照研究严重不足;因此,迫切需要新的、基于证据的方法来研究这一长期被忽视的领域。此外,先前的研究表明,儿科患者的安慰剂反应大于成人,并且在没有任何药物治疗的情况下观察到的发作频率减少在儿科偏头痛患者中比在成人中更为常见。除了这些初步考虑之外,偏头痛发作的持续时间较短以及儿童临床特征的其他特征性半表型特征使得在发育期比在成人中设计随机对照试验 (RCT) 更成问题。考虑到所有这些弱点,本综述的目的是总结和更新最近针对儿童和青少年原发性偏头痛治疗的指南。最新的指南是由意大利头痛研究学会、法国偏头痛和头痛研究学会以及美国神经病学学会发布的。我们将 2004 年以来发表的少数最近的 RCT、临床对照试验、开放标签研究、荟萃分析和综述的结果纳入了这些指南;由于该研究领域的证据不足,我们有时甚至提到了试点非对照研究、病例系列和专家意见。最后,对证据进行了分类,并根据不同级别对建议进行了分类。