Callahan Rebecca, Wilkinson Lindsey, Muller Chandra
University of Georgia.
Soc Sci Q. 2008;89(1):177-198. doi: 10.1111/j.1540-6237.2008.00527.x.
Immigrant adolescents' academic achievement is crucial to our future economic stability, and Mexican-origin linguistic minority youth in U.S. schools generally demonstrate lower levels of achievement. English as a Second Language (ESL) programs provide an institutional response to these students' needs, the effect of which may vary by the proportion of immigrant students in the school. MEASURES: Using propensity score matching and data from the Adolescent Health and Academic Achievement Study (AHAA) and the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health (Add Health), we estimate the effect of ESL placement on Mexican-origin achievement for first-, second-, and third-generation adolescents separately in schools with many and few immigrant students. RESULTS: The estimated effect of ESL placement varies by both immigrant concentration in the school and by students' generational status. CONCLUSIONS: We find that ESL enrollment may be protective for second-generation Mexican-origin adolescents in high immigrant concentration schools, and may prove detrimental for first-generation adolescents in contexts with few other immigrant students.
移民青少年的学业成绩对我们未来的经济稳定至关重要,而美国学校中墨西哥裔语言少数群体青年的成绩普遍较低。英语作为第二语言(ESL)项目针对这些学生的需求做出了制度性回应,其效果可能因学校中移民学生的比例而异。措施:利用倾向得分匹配以及来自青少年健康与学业成就研究(AHAA)和青少年健康全国纵向研究(Add Health)的数据,我们分别在移民学生多和少的学校中,估计了ESL安置对第一代、第二代和第三代墨西哥裔青少年成绩的影响。结果:ESL安置的估计效果因学校中的移民集中度以及学生的代际状况而异。结论:我们发现,在移民集中度高的学校中,参加ESL课程可能对第二代墨西哥裔青少年有保护作用,而在其他移民学生少的环境中,可能对第一代青少年有害。