Nottingham GP Speciality Training Programe, Nottingham Univerity Hospitals Trust, Nottingham NG5 1PB, UK.
Arch Dis Child. 2010 Aug;95(8):580-2. doi: 10.1136/adc.2009.168856. Epub 2010 Apr 6.
To assess the reliability and accuracy of medical advice, over a range of types of websites, found using the Google search engine, thus simulating a patient's experience.
Advice was sought for five common paediatric questions using the Google search engine. The first 100 results of each question were classified as either being consistent or inconsistent with current recommendations or as 'no answer given'. Record of the type of site and its visibility was noted.
39% of the 500 sites searched gave correct information; 11% were incorrect and 49% failed to answer the question. Where an answer was available, 78% of sites gave the correct information. The accuracy of information varied depending on the topic and ranged from 51% (mumps, measles and rubella and autism) to 100% (breast feeding with mastitis/the sleeping position of a baby). Governmental sites gave uniformly accurate advice. News sites gave correct advice in 55% of cases. No sponsored sites were encountered that gave the correct advice.
The authors have shown that the advice on the internet is very variable. Patients are known to use the internet for their own research and as such the authors encourage healthcare workers to recommend government or NHS websites.
评估使用谷歌搜索引擎搜索到的各种类型网站上的医疗建议的可靠性和准确性,从而模拟患者的体验。
使用谷歌搜索引擎搜索五个常见的儿科问题,并寻求建议。对每个问题的前 100 个结果进行分类,分为与当前建议一致、不一致或未给出答案。记录网站类型及其可见度。
在搜索的 500 个网站中,有 39%的网站提供了正确的信息;11%的网站提供了错误的信息,49%的网站没有回答问题。在有答案的情况下,78%的网站提供了正确的信息。信息的准确性取决于主题,范围从 51%(腮腺炎、麻疹和风疹和自闭症)到 100%(乳腺炎时的母乳喂养/婴儿的睡眠姿势)。政府网站提供的建议始终准确。新闻网站在 55%的情况下提供了正确的建议。未发现提供正确建议的赞助网站。
作者表明,互联网上的建议非常多样化。患者已知会自行在互联网上进行研究,因此作者鼓励医护人员推荐政府或 NHS 网站。