Paul Peter V, Lee Chongmin
School of Teaching and Learning, College of Education and Human Ecology, Ohio State University, Columbus, USA.
Am Ann Deaf. 2010 Winter;154(5):456-62; discussion 493-6. doi: 10.1353/aad.0.0125.
Evidence is presented for the qualitative similarity hypothesis (QSH) with respect to children and adolescents who are d/Deaf or hard of hearing. The primary focus is on the development of English language and literacy skills, and some information is provided on the acquisition of English as a second language. The QSH is briefly discussed within the purview of two groups of cognitive models: those that emphasize the cognitive development of individuals and those that pertain to disciplinary or knowledge structures. It is argued that the QSH has scientific merit with implications for classroom instruction. Future research should examine the validity of the QSH in other disciplines such as mathematics and science and should include perspectives from social as well as cognitive models.
本文提供了关于失聪或听力障碍儿童及青少年的质性相似性假设(QSH)的证据。主要关注的是英语语言和读写能力的发展,并提供了一些关于将英语作为第二语言习得的信息。在两组认知模型的范围内简要讨论了QSH:一组强调个体的认知发展,另一组涉及学科或知识结构。本文认为,QSH具有科学价值,对课堂教学具有启示意义。未来的研究应检验QSH在数学和科学等其他学科中的有效性,并应纳入社会模型和认知模型的观点。