The Department of Nursing, University of Haifa, Israel.
J Adv Nurs. 2010 Apr;66(4):794-805. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2648.2010.05294.x.
This paper is a report of a study conducted to identify and test the effectiveness of learning mechanisms applied by the nursing staff of hospital wards as a means of limiting medication administration errors.
Since the influential report ;To Err Is Human', research has emphasized the role of team learning in reducing medication administration errors. Nevertheless, little is known about the mechanisms underlying team learning.
Thirty-two hospital wards were randomly recruited. Data were collected during 2006 in Israel by a multi-method (observations, interviews and administrative data), multi-source (head nurses, bedside nurses) approach. Medication administration error was defined as any deviation from procedures, policies and/or best practices for medication administration, and was identified using semi-structured observations of nurses administering medication. Organizational learning was measured using semi-structured interviews with head nurses, and the previous year's reported medication administration errors were assessed using administrative data.
The interview data revealed four learning mechanism patterns employed in an attempt to learn from medication administration errors: integrated, non-integrated, supervisory and patchy learning. Regression analysis results demonstrated that whereas the integrated pattern of learning mechanisms was associated with decreased errors, the non-integrated pattern was associated with increased errors. Supervisory and patchy learning mechanisms were not associated with errors.
Superior learning mechanisms are those that represent the whole cycle of team learning, are enacted by nurses who administer medications to patients, and emphasize a system approach to data analysis instead of analysis of individual cases.
本研究旨在识别和测试病房护理人员所采用的学习机制,以限制给药错误。
自具有影响力的报告《人非圣贤,孰能无过》发表以来,研究强调了团队学习在减少给药错误中的作用。然而,团队学习的机制知之甚少。
随机招募了 32 个病房。2006 年在以色列采用了多方法(观察、访谈和行政数据)、多来源(护士长、床边护士)的方法收集数据。给药错误被定义为任何偏离给药程序、政策和/或最佳实践的行为,并通过对护士给药的半结构化观察来识别。使用护士长的半结构化访谈来衡量组织学习,使用行政数据评估前一年报告的给药错误。
访谈数据揭示了从给药错误中学习所采用的四种学习机制模式:整合、非整合、监督和零散学习。回归分析结果表明,整合的学习机制模式与错误减少相关,而非整合的学习机制模式与错误增加相关。监督和零散的学习机制与错误无关。
更好的学习机制是那些代表团队学习整个周期的机制,由为患者给药的护士实施,并强调系统的数据分析方法,而不是分析个别案例。