NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies & Columbia University Earth Institute, New York, New York 10025, USA.
Environ Sci Technol. 2010 Jun 1;44(11):4050-62. doi: 10.1021/es903884a.
The global climate problem becomes tractable if CO(2) emissions from coal use are phased out rapidly and emissions from unconventional fossil fuels (e.g., oil shale and tar sands) are prohibited. This paper outlines technology options for phasing out coal emissions in the United States by approximately 2030. We focus on coal for physical and practical reasons and on the U.S. because it is most responsible for accumulated fossil fuel CO(2) in the atmosphere today, specifically targeting electricity production, which is the primary use of coal. While we recognize that coal emissions must be phased out globally, we believe U.S. leadership is essential. A major challenge for reducing U.S. emissions is that coal provides the largest proportion of base load power, i.e., power satisfying minimum electricity demand. Because this demand is relatively constant and coal has a high carbon intensity, utility carbon emissions are largely due to coal. The current U.S. electric grid incorporates little renewable power, most of which is not base load power. However, this can readily be changed within the next 2-3 decades. Eliminating coal emissions also requires improved efficiency, a "smart grid", additional energy storage, and advanced nuclear power. Any further coal usage must be accompanied by carbon capture and storage (CCS). We suggest that near-term emphasis should be on efficiency measures and substitution of coal-fired power by renewables and third-generation nuclear plants, since these technologies have been successfully demonstrated at the relevant (commercial) scale. Beyond 2030, these measures can be supplemented by CCS at power plants and, as needed, successfully demonstrated fourth-generation reactors. We conclude that U.S. coal emissions could be phased out by 2030 using existing technologies or ones that could be commercially competitive with coal within about a decade. Elimination of fossil fuel subsidies and a substantial rising price on carbon emissions are the root requirements for a clean, emissions-free future.
如果能迅速淘汰煤炭使用产生的二氧化碳排放,并禁止使用非常规化石燃料(如油页岩和油砂),那么全球气候问题就可以得到解决。本文概述了 2030 年前逐步淘汰美国煤炭排放的技术选择。我们选择煤炭作为研究对象主要是出于实际和技术方面的原因,而选择美国则是因为其对当今大气中积累的化石燃料二氧化碳负有最大责任,特别是针对发电这一煤炭的主要用途。虽然我们认识到必须在全球范围内逐步淘汰煤炭排放,但我们认为美国的领导作用至关重要。减少美国排放的主要挑战在于,煤炭提供了最大比例的基荷电力,即满足最低电力需求的电力。由于这种需求相对稳定,而煤炭的碳强度又很高,因此公用事业的碳排放主要来自煤炭。目前美国的电网几乎没有可再生能源,而大部分可再生能源都不是基荷电力。然而,这在未来 2-3 十年内可以很容易地改变。消除煤炭排放还需要提高效率、建立“智能电网”、增加能源存储和发展先进核能。任何进一步的煤炭使用都必须伴随着碳捕获和封存(CCS)。我们建议,近期应重点关注提高效率的措施,并通过可再生能源和第三代核电站替代火力发电,因为这些技术已经在相关(商业)规模上得到了成功验证。到 2030 年以后,可以在电厂中采用 CCS 技术,如有必要,还可以成功应用第四代反应堆。我们的结论是,到 2030 年,使用现有的或在未来十年内可以在商业上与煤炭竞争的技术,就可以逐步淘汰美国的煤炭排放。消除化石燃料补贴和对碳排放征收高昂价格是实现清洁、无排放未来的根本要求。