Department of Medicine (Neurology), and Research Centre of Heart, Brain, Hormone and Healthy Aging, University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong.
Int J Stroke. 2010 Apr;5(2):74-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1747-4949.2010.00411.x.
The National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale (NIHSS) is an integral part of acute stroke assessment. We report our experience with new Putonghua- and Cantonese-Chinese language NIHSS (PC-NIHSS and CC-NIHSS) training and certification videos.
A professional video production company was hired to create the training and certification videos for both PC-NIHSS and CC-NIHSS. Two training and certification workshops were held in Chengdu and Beijing, and two workshops in Hong Kong. The instruction, training and group A certification videos were presented to workshop attendees. Unweighted kappa statistics were used to measure the agreement among raters, and the inter-rater agreements for PC-NIHSS and CC-NIHSS videos were compared with those of original English language NIHSS (E-NIHSS) videos.
The pass rates using PC-NIHSS and CC-NIHSS videos were 79% and 82%, respectively. All possible responses on individual scale items were included. Facial palsy and limb ataxia (13%) showed poor agreement, nine (60%) to 10 (67%) items showed moderate agreement (0.4<kappa<0.75), and three (20%) to four (27%) items showed excellent agreement. When compared with E-NIHSS videos, the agreements on best gaze, visual fields, facial weakness and aphasia were less for PC-NIHSS videos, and the agreements on commands for level of consciousness and visual fields were less for CC-NIHSS videos. Nevertheless, there was no difference between PC-NIHSS or CC-NIHSS and E-NIHSS videos in the agreement on total score.
Compared with E-NIHSS videos, PC-NIHSS and CC-NIHSS videos show good content validity and inter-rater reliability. Availability of these videos may facilitate the proper use of NIHSS among physicians and nurses in Putonghua- or Cantonese-speaking communities.
美国国立卫生研究院卒中量表(NIHSS)是急性卒中评估的重要组成部分。我们报告了新的普通话和粤语 NIHSS(PC-NIHSS 和 CC-NIHSS)培训和认证视频的经验。
聘请了一家专业的视频制作公司来制作 PC-NIHSS 和 CC-NIHSS 的培训和认证视频。在成都和北京举办了两次培训和认证研讨会,在香港举办了两次研讨会。向与会者展示了指导、培训和小组 A 认证视频。使用未加权 Kappa 统计量来衡量评分者之间的一致性,并将 PC-NIHSS 和 CC-NIHSS 视频的组内一致性与原始英语 NIHSS(E-NIHSS)视频进行比较。
使用 PC-NIHSS 和 CC-NIHSS 视频的通过率分别为 79%和 82%。个体量表项目的所有可能反应均包括在内。面瘫和肢体共济失调(13%)的一致性较差,9(60%)至 10(67%)项为中度一致性(0.4<kappa<0.75),3(20%)至 4(27%)项为高度一致性。与 E-NIHSS 视频相比,PC-NIHSS 视频在最佳注视、视野、面部无力和失语症方面的一致性较差,CC-NIHSS 视频在意识水平和视野方面的命令一致性较差。然而,PC-NIHSS 或 CC-NIHSS 与 E-NIHSS 视频在总分的一致性方面没有差异。
与 E-NIHSS 视频相比,PC-NIHSS 和 CC-NIHSS 视频具有良好的内容有效性和评分者间可靠性。这些视频的可用性可能有助于讲普通话或粤语的医生和护士正确使用 NIHSS。