Department of Agricultural and Resource Economics, University of California, Davis, 95616, USA.
Ecol Lett. 2010 Apr;13(4):528-41. doi: 10.1111/j.1461-0248.2010.01440.x.
We review studies that address economically optimal control of established invasive species. We describe three important components for determining optimal invasion management: invasion dynamics, costs of control efforts and a monetary measure of invasion damages. We find that a management objective that explicitly considers both costs and damages is most appropriate for determining economically optimal strategies, but also leads to large challenges due to uncertainty in components of the management problem. To address uncertainty, some studies have included stochasticity in their models; others have quantified the value of information or focused on decision-making with limited information. Our synthesis shows how invasion characteristics, such as costs, damages, pattern of spread and invasion and landscape size, affect optimal control strategies and goals in systematic ways. We find that even for simple questions, such as whether control should be applied at the centre of an invasion or to satellite patches, the answer depends on the details of a particular invasion. Future work should seek to better quantify key components of this problem, determine best management in the face of limited information, improve understanding of spatial aspects of invasion control and design approaches to improve the feasibility of achieving regional control goals.
我们回顾了有关已建立入侵物种经济最优控制的研究。我们描述了确定最优入侵管理的三个重要组成部分:入侵动态、控制努力的成本以及入侵损害的货币衡量。我们发现,明确考虑成本和损害的管理目标最适合确定经济最优策略,但由于管理问题的组成部分存在不确定性,也会带来巨大的挑战。为了解决不确定性,一些研究在其模型中纳入了随机性;另一些研究则量化了信息的价值,或侧重于有限信息下的决策。我们的综述表明,入侵特征(如成本、损害、传播模式以及入侵和景观规模)如何以系统的方式影响最优控制策略和目标。我们发现,即使是对于简单的问题,例如是否应在入侵中心或卫星斑块处进行控制,答案也取决于特定入侵的细节。未来的工作应致力于更好地量化这个问题的关键组成部分,在信息有限的情况下确定最佳管理方法,提高对入侵控制空间方面的理解,并设计方法来提高实现区域控制目标的可行性。