VA Boston Healthcare System and Harvard Medical School, Brockton, MA, USA. michael
Behav Brain Res. 2010 Dec 25;214(2):180-6. doi: 10.1016/j.bbr.2010.05.020. Epub 2010 May 21.
Sleep disruption results in an increased demand for energy, which typically causes hyperphagia in an attempt to redress the energy metabolism imbalance. Therefore, experiments combining food reward and sleep disruption may underestimate the effect of sleep disruption due to their contradictory influences on behavior (for example on operant measures of attention). In contrast, water is not a central component of energy metabolism and thus thirst may not be affected by sleep disruption. However, little work has been done examining the effect of sleep disruption on thirst and motivation for water. The effect of total sleep deprivation (SD) and experimental sleep fragmentation (SF) on thirst and motivation for water was assessed. In experiment 1 (using 22 month old male Fisher-Norway rats) the amount of water consumed during a 15 min period immediately following a period of 24h SD or SF (in which water was not available) was measured, and, in a separate session, the amount of water consumed during the 24h of SD or SF was measured. Thereafter, the effect of 5 days SD or SF on motivation for water was assessed with the progressive ratio task (using water reward), which is widely used to assess motivation. Experiment 2 (using 6 month, and 22 month, old male Sprague- Dawley rats) followed an identical design except that the SF condition was dropped (due to a lack of any difference between the SD and SF conditions in experiment 1), and only the 6 month old rats experienced the full 5 day SD condition. Daily measurements of body weight and food consumption were recorded in experiment 2 in order to confirm previously published findings that food consumption goes up and body weight declines in sleep deprived rats. In both experiments the quantity of water rats consumed during a 15 min period immediately following the 24h period of sleep disruption, or consumed during the 24h period of SD or SF, did not change compared to control rats. Furthermore, 5 days of SD or SF had no effect on breakpoint in the progressive ratio task indicating that 5 days of SD or SF did not alter motivation for water reward. As previously reported, food consumption increased and body weight decreased during the 5 days of SD. in experiment 2. The findings indicate that although sleep disruption increases food consumption and decreases body weight, it does not alter thirst or motivation for water reward. Thus, water restriction is well suited for experiments examining the effect of sleep disruption on reward motivated behavioral tests in rats.
睡眠中断会导致能量需求增加,这通常会导致过度进食,以试图纠正能量代谢失衡。因此,将食物奖励与睡眠中断结合起来的实验可能会低估睡眠中断的影响,因为它们对行为有相反的影响(例如对操作性注意措施的影响)。相比之下,水不是能量代谢的核心组成部分,因此睡眠中断可能不会影响口渴。然而,很少有研究探讨睡眠中断对口渴和水的动机的影响。评估了完全睡眠剥夺 (SD) 和实验性睡眠碎片化 (SF) 对口渴和水的动机的影响。在实验 1(使用 22 个月大的雄性 Fisher-Norway 大鼠)中,测量了在经历 24 小时 SD 或 SF(在此期间水不可用)后的 15 分钟内消耗的水量,并且在单独的时段中,测量了在 24 小时 SD 或 SF 期间消耗的水量。此后,使用广泛用于评估动机的渐进比例任务评估了 5 天 SD 或 SF 对水的动机的影响。实验 2(使用 6 个月和 22 个月大的雄性 Sprague-Dawley 大鼠)采用了相同的设计,只是由于在实验 1 中 SD 和 SF 条件之间没有差异,因此取消了 SF 条件,并且只有 6 个月大的大鼠经历了完整的 5 天 SD 条件。实验 2 中每天记录体重和食物消耗的测量值,以确认先前发表的发现,即睡眠剥夺的大鼠食物消耗增加,体重下降。在这两个实验中,大鼠在经历 24 小时睡眠中断后立即的 15 分钟内消耗的水量,或在 24 小时的 SD 或 SF 期间消耗的水量与对照大鼠相比没有变化。此外,5 天的 SD 或 SF 对渐进比例任务中的断点没有影响,这表明 5 天的 SD 或 SF 没有改变对水奖励的动机。如前所述,在实验 2 的 5 天 SD 期间,食物消耗增加,体重下降。研究结果表明,尽管睡眠中断会增加食物消耗并降低体重,但它不会改变口渴或对水奖励的动机。因此,水限制非常适合研究睡眠中断对大鼠奖励动机行为测试的影响的实验。