Division of General Internal Medicine, University of California, Davis Medical Center, 4150 V Street, Suite 2400, Sacramento, CA 95817, USA.
Nicotine Tob Res. 2010 Jul;12(7):724-33. doi: 10.1093/ntr/ntq071. Epub 2010 May 27.
Tobacco dependence treatment efforts have focused on primary care physicians (PCPs), but evidence suggests that they are insufficient to help most smokers quit. Other health professionals also frequently encounter smokers, but their smoking prevalence, cessation practices, and beliefs are less well known.
The study included 2,804 subjects from seven health professional groups: PCPs, emergency medicine physicians, psychiatrists, registered nurses, dentists, dental hygienists, and pharmacists. Outcomes included self-reported smoking status, smoking cessation practices, and beliefs. Multivariate regression was used to examine factors associated with health professionals (except pharmacists) self-reportedly performing the "5 A's": asking, advising, assessing, assisting, or arranging follow-up about tobacco.
Health professionals have a low smoking prevalence (<6%), except nurses (13%). Many health professionals report asking (87.3%-99.5%) and advising (65.6%-94.9%) about smoking but much less assessing smokers' interest (38.7%-84.8%), assisting (16.4%-63.7%), and arranging follow-up (1.3%-23.1%). Controlling for health professional and practice demographics, factors positively associated in the multivariate analyses with self-reportedly performing multiple components of the 5 A's include awareness of the Public Health Service guidelines, having had cessation training, and believing that treatment was an important professional responsibility. Negative associations include the health professional being a current smoker, not being a PCP, being uncomfortable asking patients if they smoke, believing counseling was not an appropriate service, and reporting competing priorities.
U.S. health professionals report not fully performing the 5 A's. The common barriers and facilitators identified may help inform strategies for increasing the involvement of all health professionals in conducting tobacco dependence treatments.
烟草依赖治疗工作主要集中在初级保健医生(PCP)身上,但有证据表明,这不足以帮助大多数吸烟者戒烟。其他卫生专业人员也经常遇到吸烟者,但他们的吸烟率、戒烟做法和信念却知之甚少。
该研究包括来自七个卫生专业群体的 2804 名受试者:PCP、急诊医师、精神科医师、注册护士、牙医、牙科保健师和药剂师。结果包括自我报告的吸烟状况、戒烟做法和信念。多变量回归用于检查与卫生专业人员(除药剂师外)自我报告的“5A”行为相关的因素:询问、建议、评估、协助或安排有关烟草的随访。
卫生专业人员的吸烟率较低(<6%),除护士(13%)外。许多卫生专业人员报告询问(87.3%-99.5%)和建议(65.6%-94.9%)关于吸烟的问题,但对吸烟者的兴趣评估(38.7%-84.8%)、协助(16.4%-63.7%)和安排随访(1.3%-23.1%)的报告较少。在控制卫生专业人员和实践人口统计学因素后,多元分析中与自我报告执行“5A”多个组成部分相关的积极因素包括了解公共卫生服务指南、接受过戒烟培训以及认为治疗是一项重要的专业责任。消极因素包括卫生专业人员是当前吸烟者、不是 PCP、不自在地询问患者是否吸烟、认为咨询不是一项适当的服务以及报告有竞争优先级。
美国卫生专业人员报告没有充分执行“5A”。确定的常见障碍和促进因素可能有助于为增加所有卫生专业人员参与烟草依赖治疗提供策略。