Martelli C, Awad H, Hardy P
U669, université Paris-Sud, Le Kremlin-Bicêtre, France.
Encephale. 2010 Jun;36 Suppl 2:D83-91. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2009.06.011. Epub 2009 Sep 26.
Few studies have been devoted to in-patients' suicides. This covers all suicides that occurred during hospitalisation, whatever the place (inside or outside the institution) and often, for psychiatric in-patients, suicides carried out within 24 hours after leaving the institution.
However, the incidence of suicide in hospital is high, higher than that observed in the general population. It is 250 per 100,000 admissions in psychiatric hospitals and 1.8 per 100,000 admissions in general hospitals, which is four to five times more than in general population. Five to 6.5% of suicides are committed in the hospital: 3 to 5.5% occur in psychiatric hospitals and about 2% in general hospitals. Many risk factors for suicide were identified in this context. The accessibility to one or more means of suicide (water, rail, high floor [third floor or beyond], knives, possibility of hanging...) is a recognized factor in psychiatric institutions. In the psychiatric environment, hospitalisation period also determines the risk of suicide: it is highest during the 1st week of hospitalisation and within 2 weeks after leaving. The same is true for the conditions of care: inadequate supervision, the underestimation of the risk of suicide by teams, poor communication within the teams and the lack of intensive care unit promote suicide risk. The controlled studies conducted in a psychiatric environment distinguish two periods for identifying risk factors. The first period is the time of hospitalisation. Are recognized as risk factors: the existence of suicidal personal history (but also family) and attempted suicide shortly before admission, the diagnosis of schizophrenia or mood disorder (non-controlled studies also emphasize the importance of alcoholic comorbidity), being hospitalised without consent, living alone, absence from the service without permission. The second period covers the time-period immediately following the hospitalisation. For this period, risk factors are: the existence of personal history of suicide and suicidal ideation or attempt of suicide shortly before admission (but also attempt of suicide during hospitalisation), the existence of relational difficulties, the existence of stress or loss of employment, living alone, a decision on leaving the hospital unplanned and lack of contact with nursing in the immediate postdischarge period. In general hospitals, the chronicity and severity of the somatic disease, the personality of the patient and the existence of a psychiatric comorbidity are the suicidal factors most often quoted. Furthermore, we also found only a low rate of psychiatric consultation during the hospitalisation of patient who will commit suicide. Among the countries which have a national program of suicide prevention, only England registered the question of the in-patients suicide among its priorities. The elements of a prevention policy appear however in certain scientific publications and some programs of local or regional initiative. These elements can be grouped under five items: securing the hospital environment, optimisation of the care of the patients at suicidal risk, training of the medical teams in the detection of the risk and in the care of the suicidal subjects, involvement of the families in the care and implementation of post-event procedures following a completed suicide or an attempt.
很少有研究关注住院患者自杀问题。这涵盖了住院期间发生的所有自杀行为,无论地点(机构内或机构外),对于精神科住院患者而言,还包括出院后24小时内实施的自杀行为。
然而,医院内自杀发生率很高,高于普通人群。在精神病医院每10万例入院患者中有250例自杀,在综合医院每10万例入院患者中有1.8例自杀,是普通人群的四到五倍。5%至6.5%的自杀行为发生在医院:3%至5.5%发生在精神病医院,约2%发生在综合医院。在这种情况下确定了许多自杀风险因素。能够获取一种或多种自杀手段(水、铁路、高层[三楼及以上]、刀具、上吊可能性……)是精神病机构中公认的因素。在精神科环境中,住院时间也决定自杀风险:在住院第一周及出院后两周内风险最高。护理条件也是如此:监督不足、团队对自杀风险的低估、团队内部沟通不畅以及缺乏重症监护病房都会增加自杀风险。在精神科环境中进行的对照研究区分了识别风险因素的两个时期。第一个时期是住院期间。被视为风险因素的有:有自杀个人史(以及家族史)且入院前不久有自杀未遂情况、精神分裂症或情绪障碍诊断(非对照研究也强调酒精共病的重要性)、未经同意住院、独居、擅自离开病房。第二个时期涵盖住院后紧接着的时间段。对于这个时期,风险因素有:有自杀个人史且入院前不久有自杀意念或自杀未遂情况(以及住院期间自杀未遂)、存在人际关系困难、存在压力或失业、独居、未经计划决定出院以及出院后立即与护理人员缺乏联系。在综合医院,躯体疾病的慢性程度和严重程度、患者个性以及存在精神科共病是最常被提及的自杀因素。此外,我们还发现自杀患者住院期间精神科会诊率很低。在有国家自杀预防计划的国家中,只有英国将住院患者自杀问题列为优先事项。然而,预防政策的要素出现在某些科学出版物以及一些地方或区域倡议项目中。这些要素可归为五项:确保医院环境安全、优化对有自杀风险患者的护理、对医疗团队进行自杀风险检测及自杀患者护理方面的培训、让家属参与护理以及在发生自杀或自杀未遂事件后实施后续程序。