Czosek Richard J, Anderson Jeffery, Marino Bradley S, Connor Chad, Knilans Timothy K
Heart Center, Department of Pediatrics, Division of Pediatric Cardiology, Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, Cincinnati, OH 45229, USA.
Pacing Clin Electrophysiol. 2010 Nov;33(11):1304-11. doi: 10.1111/j.1540-8159.2010.02811.x.
Radiofrequency (RF) ablation is a relatively safe and effective method for treatment of atrioventricular nodal re-entry tachycardia (AVNRT), but carries a 1-2% risk of AV nodal injury. Cryothermal ablation reduces the risk of AV block, but has had decreased procedural success and increased recurrence of tachycardia. We sought to evaluate the technique of linear lesion cryoablation (LLC) for treatment of AVNRT.
Single institution retrospective cohort study. Each patient underwent slow pathway modification using either RF, single lesion cryoablation, or LLC. Procedural success, recurrence, freedom from tachycardia 12 months following ablation and fluoroscopy time were compared between ablation methods.
A total of 125 patients, median age 15.5 (4.7-23.1) years, underwent ablation: 32 RF energy, 31 single lesion cryoablation, 62 LLC. Procedural success was obtained in 94% of the LLC group compared to 58% using single lesion cryoablation (P ≤ 0.001). Ninety-seven percent of the LLC group was free from tachycardia recurrence, significantly higher than with single lesion cryoablation (68%, P = 0.001) and equal to that of RF (97%, P = NS). Fluoroscopy time was reduced in the LLC group compared to both single lesion and RF groups (P = 0.02). There was no permanent AV nodal injury in the cryoablation groups.
LLC is an effective means of treatment for AVNRT and is associated with significantly improved procedural success and freedom from recurrence compared to single lesion methods, while at the same time obtaining equivalent efficacy to RF.
射频(RF)消融是治疗房室结折返性心动过速(AVNRT)的一种相对安全有效的方法,但存在1%-2%的房室结损伤风险。冷冻消融降低了房室传导阻滞的风险,但手术成功率降低且心动过速复发率增加。我们试图评估线性病变冷冻消融(LLC)治疗AVNRT的技术。
单机构回顾性队列研究。每位患者采用RF、单病变冷冻消融或LLC进行慢径路改良。比较消融方法之间的手术成功率、复发率、消融后12个月无心动过速情况及透视时间。
共有125例患者,中位年龄15.5(4.7-23.1)岁,接受了消融治疗:32例采用RF能量,31例采用单病变冷冻消融,62例采用LLC。LLC组手术成功率为94%,而单病变冷冻消融组为58%(P≤0.001)。LLC组97%的患者无心动过速复发,显著高于单病变冷冻消融组(68%,P=0.001),且与RF组相当(97%,P=无显著性差异)。与单病变组和RF组相比,LLC组的透视时间减少(P=0.02)。冷冻消融组无永久性房室结损伤。
LLC是治疗AVNRT的有效方法,与单病变方法相比,手术成功率显著提高且复发率降低,同时与RF具有同等疗效。