Mons F, Kwetieu de Lendeu P, Marret S, Laudenbach V
CHU Charles-Nicolle, Rouen, France.
Ann Fr Anesth Reanim. 2010 Jun;29(6):478-87. doi: 10.1016/j.annfar.2010.02.031. Epub 2010 May 26.
To expose the current knowledge about the anaesthetic effects on the developing brain.
Publications (original articles and reviews) in English and in French language from 1980 were obtained from the Medline database using alone or in combination following keywords: anaesthetics, developing brain, neurodevelopment, neurogenesis, synaptogenesis, neurotoxicity, apoptosis.
Several lines of evidence resulting from animal experiments conducted in rodents and non-human primates have suggested that exposing the developing brain to anaesthetic drugs may elicit an increase a physiological programmed neuronal death (i.e. apoptosis). This neuronal death is not only seen at the cellular level but also results in alterations in some behavioural abilities in the adult animal. However, the vast majority of experiments reported have been conducted in animals not exposed to any surgical or painful stimulation. Moreover, the literature raises contradictory results, some authors not confirming this neurotoxic effect of anaesthetic drugs. Last, available clinical data are scarce and do not allow to claim that exposure to general anaesthesia definitely alters the cognitive development of children.
This review raises the question of the innocuity of anaesthetic agents on the developing brain; further clinical trials are required in order to test this effect on human babies.
揭示目前关于麻醉药对发育中大脑影响的知识。
使用关键词“麻醉药”“发育中大脑”“神经发育”“神经发生”“突触形成”“神经毒性”“细胞凋亡”单独或组合检索Medline数据库,获取1980年以来的英文和法文出版物(原创文章和综述)。
在啮齿动物和非人类灵长类动物身上进行的多项动物实验证据表明,发育中的大脑接触麻醉药可能会引发生理性程序性神经元死亡(即细胞凋亡)增加。这种神经元死亡不仅在细胞水平可见,还会导致成年动物某些行为能力的改变。然而,绝大多数报道的实验是在未接受任何手术或疼痛刺激的动物身上进行的。此外,文献结果相互矛盾,一些作者未证实麻醉药的这种神经毒性作用。最后,现有的临床数据稀少,无法断言接触全身麻醉肯定会改变儿童的认知发育。
本综述提出了麻醉药对发育中大脑无害性的问题;需要进一步开展临床试验以测试其对人类婴儿的影响。