Leroux J L, Legeron P, Moulinier L, Laroche M, Mazières B, Blotman F, Duquesnoy B, Vignon E, Camus J P, Arlet J
Service de Rhumatologie, CHU Rangueil, Toulouse.
Rev Rhum Mal Osteoartic. 1991 May;58(5):331-7.
The authors report data collected in a study of the association of narrow lumbar canal and vertebral hyperostosis. Five centres (Montpellier, Toulouse, Lille, Lyons and Paris) participated in this cooperative study which was both retrospective and prospective. Grid case forms were sent to homogenise the date provided. Two hundred and sixty nine cases of symptomatic lumbar canal stenosis were collected; 89 (33 per cent) had hyperostosis. Hyperostosis was definite in 74 cases and probable in 15 other cases. Certain radiological and/or CT scan morphological factors seen frequently in the hyperostosis patients group led us to undertake a second study in 2 of the 5 centres (Montpellier and Toulouse) in order to identify their specificity. Twenty eight items were adopted and studied by 3 different evaluators (2 rheumatologists and one radiologist) in the X-ray films and CT scan documents of 100 patients with acquired lumbar canal stenosis with or without hyperostosis (46 and 54 cases respectively). The most discriminative appearances, which we suggest as diagnostic criteria of narrow lumbar canal with hyperostosis concern anterior and/or posterolateral marginal somatic bone proliferations on the non-articular surfaces of the posterior apophyses and ossifications of the posterior joint capsule and of the ligaments (ligamentum flavum--posterior longitudinal ligament--supraspinous ligament). Four of these 6 criteria are necessary to make the diagnosis of lumbar stenosis with hyperostosis. The radiological and CT scan appearances of lumbar hyperostosis appear to differ from ordinary degenerative changes of osteoarthrosis and hyperostosis may be held responsible for compression of the dural cul-de-sac.
作者报告了一项关于腰椎管狭窄与椎体骨质增生相关性研究中收集的数据。五个中心(蒙彼利埃、图卢兹、里尔、里昂和巴黎)参与了这项回顾性和前瞻性的合作研究。发放了标准化病例表格以使所提供的数据同质化。收集了269例有症状的腰椎管狭窄病例;其中89例(33%)有骨质增生。74例骨质增生明确,另外15例可能有骨质增生。在骨质增生患者组中经常见到的某些放射学和/或CT扫描形态学因素,促使我们在5个中心中的2个(蒙彼利埃和图卢兹)进行第二项研究,以确定其特异性。3名不同的评估人员(2名风湿病学家和1名放射科医生)采用28项指标,对100例获得性腰椎管狭窄患者(有或无骨质增生分别为46例和54例)的X线片和CT扫描资料进行研究。我们建议作为伴有骨质增生的腰椎管狭窄诊断标准的最具鉴别性的表现,涉及后突非关节面的前侧和/或后外侧边缘体部骨质增生以及后关节囊和韧带(黄韧带 - 后纵韧带 - 棘上韧带)的骨化。诊断伴有骨质增生的腰椎管狭窄需要这6项标准中的4项。腰椎骨质增生的放射学和CT扫描表现似乎不同于骨关节炎的普通退行性改变,骨质增生可能是导致硬脊膜囊受压的原因。