MRC Cognition and Brain Sciences Unit, and Cambridge Centre for Brain Repair, Forvie Site, Addenbrooke's Hosptial, 15 Chaucer Road, Cambridge CB2 7EF, UK.
Neuropsychologia. 2010 Jul;48(9):2719-29. doi: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2010.05.019. Epub 2010 May 16.
Initial reports of emotion recognition in Huntington's disease (HD) found disproportionate impairments in recognising disgust. Not all subsequent studies have found this pattern, and a review of the literature to date shows that marked impairments in recognising anger are also often seen in HD. However, the majority of studies have based their conclusions on a single test of facial expression recognition. In the current study we revisit this issue of emotion recognition in HD to address whether the pattern found on one test of facial expression recognition generalised to another, and to different modalities using tests of emotion recognition from facial expressions, vocal expressions, and short verbal vignettes. The results showed evidence of impairments in recognising anger, fear and disgust across the three domains, with recognition of anger the most severely impaired. Given work identifying different subtypes of disgust that are associated with different facial features, a second study examined the recognition of three disgust expressions that healthy participants reliably associate with unpleasant tastes, unpleasant smells, and a more general elaborated or expanded form of disgust that includes reactions to violations of moral standards. The results showed a disproportionate impairment in recognising faces associated with the expanded form, the subtype most closely aligned with anger. We conclude that the related emotions of disgust and anger associated with social disapproval are frequently impaired in HD and discuss factors that might cause one emotion to show more severe impairments than the other.
亨廷顿病(HD)中情绪识别的初步报告发现,识别厌恶的能力存在不成比例的损伤。并非所有后续研究都发现了这种模式,对迄今为止文献的综述表明,在 HD 中也经常看到识别愤怒的明显损伤。然而,大多数研究都是基于单一的面部表情识别测试来得出结论的。在当前的研究中,我们重新审视了 HD 中的情绪识别问题,以确定在面部表情识别的单一测试中发现的模式是否可以推广到另一种模式,以及使用面部表情、声音表达和简短的口头描述来进行不同模式的情绪识别。结果表明,在三个领域中都存在识别愤怒、恐惧和厌恶的损伤,其中识别愤怒的损伤最为严重。鉴于已经有研究确定了与不同面部特征相关的不同类型的厌恶,第二项研究考察了识别三种健康参与者可靠地与不愉快的味道、不愉快的气味以及更普遍的厌恶形式相关联的厌恶表情的能力,后者包括对违反道德标准的反应。结果表明,对与扩展形式相关的面部表情的识别存在不成比例的损伤,而扩展形式与愤怒最密切相关。我们得出结论,与社会不赞成相关的相关情绪——厌恶和愤怒在 HD 中经常受损,并讨论了导致一种情绪比另一种情绪损伤更严重的因素。