Department of Psychiatry and Psychology, Mayo Clinic Rochester, Rochester, MN 55905, USA.
Acad Radiol. 2010 Aug;17(8):1012-25. doi: 10.1016/j.acra.2010.04.003.
Spiral computed tomography (SCT) is being evaluated as a screening tool for lung cancer. Our objective was to describe the effect of participation in SCT screening on participants' risk perceptions, worry, and expectations regarding the accuracy of the screening result.
We surveyed 60 individuals with lung cancer family history who were participating in an SCT study for the primary purpose of improving genetic linkage analysis at baseline, and then 1 and 6 months post-SCT.
Of the 60 participants, 40 received normal results, 19 received non-negative results requiring follow-up, and 1 was diagnosed with lung cancer. At baseline, participants reported high levels of perceived lung cancer risk (64%), were concerned about developing lung cancer (94%), and the majority (84%) were not OK with receiving a non-negative SCT result when they really didn't have cancer. At 1 month post-SCT, those with a non-negative screen (n = 19) had lowered their expectations of test accuracy regarding non-negative results (54%) and reported increased levels in worry/concern (100%) and perceived risk (75%), but these effects diminished over time and returned almost to baseline levels at 6 months.
Persons at very high empiric risk for lung cancer expect their SCT screening test to be accurate and present with high levels of lung cancer risk perception and worry/concern overall. Our findings suggest a need for risk counseling and discussion on the limitations of screening tests to accurately detect lung cancer.
螺旋 CT 扫描(SCT)正被评估作为肺癌的筛查工具。我们的目的是描述参与 SCT 筛查对参与者的风险认知、对筛查结果准确性的担忧和期望的影响。
我们调查了 60 名有肺癌家族史的参与者,他们参与 SCT 研究的主要目的是提高遗传连锁分析的准确性,然后在 SCT 后 1 个月和 6 个月进行了调查。
在 60 名参与者中,40 名得到了正常结果,19 名得到了需要随访的非阴性结果,1 名被诊断为肺癌。基线时,参与者报告了较高的肺癌风险感知水平(64%),对患肺癌的担忧(94%),并且大多数(84%)人在没有癌症时不接受非阴性 SCT 结果。在 SCT 后 1 个月,那些有非阴性筛查结果的人(n=19)降低了对非阴性结果的测试准确性的期望(54%),并报告了担忧/关注程度的增加(100%)和风险感知的增加(75%),但这些影响随着时间的推移而减弱,并在 6 个月时几乎恢复到基线水平。
对肺癌有极高经验风险的人期望他们的 SCT 筛查测试是准确的,并表现出高水平的肺癌风险感知和总体担忧/关注。我们的研究结果表明,需要进行风险咨询和讨论,以了解筛查测试对准确检测肺癌的局限性。